I wish that Sam's had this pie for Christmas because i would buy more VERY GOOD PIE. I dont compliment pies and pastries that are not home made. BUT these pies are as i said VERY GOOD.

Not so good I've baught pp from Sam's every holiday, and just because they're good. But this one i bought didn't have any flavor it was BLAND couldn't taste the pumpkin, NOT GOOD also dry.

Sams has the best bakery, and the pumpkin pie is a seasonal favorite in our house. We have tried them at other warehouse stores and grocery stores and these are the best. The crust is great, which makes the pie!

I feel like they changed the recipe they normally use, or maybe I just got an old or bad pie but this year it was really off the mark. My family and I each only had one slice (which we each didn’t finish) and then it was avoided til it was tossed

Almost like homemade, but without all the work. I like to cut a thin slice and just eat it from my hand, like a good slice of pizza. Sweet, but not too sweet and the texture is nice too.

This is a great value for a pumpkin pie. The crust is tender and the filling has a great custard texture. My only "ding" is the pumpkin flavor is just a bit bland - but this is certainly a matter of taste preference. I've always preferred a pumpkin pie with a slightly more intense flavor of the cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg spices typically used in these pies, but this is still a delicious pie - worthy of year round enjoyment!

One of my children loves pumpkin pie and that is the reason we again purchased this. First time I bought it was last month for thanksgiving and now doing same for Christmas. Can't complain about the price and it was cheaper this time around. It has my son's approval and ours too

Bought it because it was so cheap at only $6. The taste was a 4 out of 5 stars, better than most store-bought pumpkin pies. It lasted more than a week after it expired without getting bad and making us sick, lol. Best thing was the extra extra large size. I bought it because it was recommended by a friend also.

I can't wait for the time of the year when Sam's Club starts selling their Member's Mark pumpkin pie. That's one big pie and a great cost. I live alone and eat the whole pie myself. Besides being very healthy, I love the texture and taste. It lasts a long time in the refrigerator. I am always sad when they discontinue it after the holidays.

For as many years as Sam’s Club has been in business, my family has been eaten this pumpkin pie to the exclusion of any other bakery’s pie. This pie is bigger than anyone else pie so it will feed the entire Thanksgiving guest list. And I always have to mention the pocketbook, my costs are always uppermost in my mind. You can buy this pie, you won’t be sorry!