Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 12" Pumpkin Pie, 58 oz. for
Member's Mark 12" Pumpkin Pie, 58 oz.
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars7,209 ratings1,825 reviews
  1. 5 stars78% (5,640)
  2. 4 stars10% (692)
  3. 3 stars6% (399)
  4. 2 stars3% (221)
  5. 1 star4% (257)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 121-130 of 1,825 reviews
Oct 26, 2025
Pbmiracle
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Pumpkin Pie for a Party

Great taste, large enough for big family or bring to office party.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 8, 2023
JP
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Not like homemade or my old warehouse company.

Sam's Pumpkin pies are just okay. The pies are a bit dry and not the most flavorful. In comparison, I used to get these from another warehouse company which are made onsite and are very good - moist, fresh, and flavorful.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Sep 27, 2024
Garfy
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

OK but needs better crust

The pumpkin filling was OK but the crust leaves a lot to be desired. The texture and crispness just wasn't there. However, the price was lower than most other places with such a large pie.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Oct 21, 2023
SherriBerri
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Was disappointed with the flavor and texture

Wasn’t as flavorful as pumpkin pie should be and also had a strange texture. I have made pumpkin pie from scratch and had many different store bought pumpkin pie and this one is the first one I didn’t like.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Oct 1, 2025
Donna
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Pumpkin pie

It was dry

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Oct 5, 2025
Lion6870
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Wish they had a smaller version for single people

Tasty pie great price

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Dec 3, 2023
Pumpkin Lover
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Better Before

Disappointing again. Several years ago, these were the best pumpkin pies sold in any store. Flaky crust with a creamy pumpkin, spiced perfection. They flew off the bakery tables as other customers seemed to enjoy them too. Why change the recipe? That was a big mistake.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 4, 2023
DisplayNamesHaveBeenTaken
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Sorry Linus - I just at the Great Pumpkin!

Usually when I purchase something that costs less than making it myself, it's a big disappointment. That's not the case here! Perfect pumpkin pie. They got the spices right and it actually tastes like pumpkin- not squash. Reminds me of my Nana's pumpkin pie but twice the size. It's a bit too easy to overserve, but I'm glad it's not pre-sliced. Hey - I only had one piece!

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Dec 13, 2024
MomoT
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Too Sweet, Too Doughy

Too much sugar in the filling; the sweetness totally overshadowed and outplayed the flavor of the pumpkin making it almost inconceivable to finish even a single slice. Additionally the pie shell was too thick resulting in a very heavy and “doughy” crust. The price was its only saving Grace.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 1, 2024
Protect And Serve
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

12" Pumpkin Pie By Members Mark:

Excellent value and so very tasty. The crust at times is dry or seems to dark. Our preference. The side's and bottom are not dry. I know I've had this happen to me. Honestly, this pie is so large and great tasting that it doesn't make much sense for me to buy the ingredients and spend the required baking time needed to bake one. Not saying having the satisfaction of baking one your self isn't gratifying. I personally have limited free time. I choose to provide our family with a wonderful better tasting pie from Sam's Club. NOTE: Buy early they go fast. We purchase 2 or 3 extras and freeze them. Keep the pie off any iced shelf's. Ours have kept for up to 6 months. Enjoy...

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796