I decided to do ta taste test between the frozen one, and the one with the clear lid in the bakery case. The texture of this one is heavier, and It,s sweet. $12.98. The one in the bakery case with the clear lid is creamier and less sweet. I give the one in the bakery a 5 star. $12.49. Don't get the multi-colored one in the bakery. $14.98. Although all Makers Mark, All are different bakeries.

This cheesecake was so creamy and delicious! In my husband and my opinion it is better than the Cheesecake Factory cheesecake! It came already pre sliced and is frozen! We put it in the fridge a day before we were going to eat it and it was completely thawed when we served it! Our guests loved it too! I made a strawberry topping for it but it honestly did not need a topping it was so good! I will buy another one to have in the freezer for future dinner parties!

I love this New York style cheesecake so much that I buy one every time I go shopping at Sam's Club. In fact, if I run out and my daughter or sister are going to be at Sam's, I ask them to pick one up for me! Authentic New York style and delicious - it keeps well in the freezer so it's very convenient.

This was the first store-bought cheesecake my picky husband has liked. It is much better than the bakery case one at Sam’s. It is a bit sweeter than some I’ve tried but the flavor and texture are good. Definitely recommend it. Add fruit topping of your choice and a instant lavish dessert.

Have been buying this cheesecake for couple of years now. Never had the time for the feedback of this cheesecake. All I can say it’s worth every penny, the taste and the crust is just perfect. If you ever eaten at Cheesecake Factory, it taste as good as that but cheaper. You won’t be disappointed. Will be purchasing one for Thanksgiving this year for sure. Please don’t ever discontinue this product.

This cheesecake was better than any I've had in a restaurant and I am a "foodie". It was creamy and smooth w/o the typical cheap burnt pan edge crust taste. Topped it (fed 80 people) with chocolate drizzle or heated strawberry jam w/whipped cream...excellent!!

What is it not to love about this cheesecake? I enjoy the precut portions, taste, and freshness.

Fantastic cheese cake without a strong lemon taste! It's perfect!

Cheesecake is so good

Really good taste