Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 9" New York Style Cheesecake, Frozen, 12 slices for
Member's Mark 9" New York Style Cheesecake, Frozen, 12 slices
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars3,225 ratings931 reviews
  1. 5 stars86% (2,758)
  2. 4 stars7% (236)
  3. 3 stars3% (98)
  4. 2 stars2% (50)
  5. 1 star3% (83)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 851-860 of 931 reviews
Aug 16, 2017
M stump
4 out of 5 stars review

heavy and sweet

I decided to do ta taste test between the frozen one, and the one with the clear lid in the bakery case. The texture of this one is heavier, and It,s sweet. $12.98. The one in the bakery case with the clear lid is creamier and less sweet. I give the one in the bakery a 5 star. $12.49. Don't get the multi-colored one in the bakery. $14.98. Although all Makers Mark, All are different bakeries.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Mar 22, 2021
DSHealy
5 out of 5 stars review

The real deal

Having grown up in New York, I'm usually disappointed in 'New York' style cheesecakes. But this is the real deal. Sweet, creamy, full bodied and delicious. It will hold it's own with most genuine New York cheesecakes. And the price can't be beat! Just defrost a piece and then dig in.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Apr 28, 2024
DFranch
5 out of 5 stars review

Will buy again!

I wanted 2 pieces of cheesecake, not a whole cheesecake. Since this is pre-sliced, I can take one or two out or the freezer whenever I feel like a slice. I was surprised how good it was, especially for the price. I will definitely buy again. It is creamy, and has good flavor, and for a quarter of the price of a cheesecake factory cheesecake.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Dec 12, 2021
Sams customer
2 out of 5 stars review

Purchased for daughter's licensure celebration

I purchased this cheesecake to celebrate my daughter becoming a certified electrical engineer. Cheesecake is one of her favorite desserts. This cheesecake was one of the biggest disappointments I have ever purchased from Sam's, and that's saying a lot. After having dinner, we each had a piece, and as we both bit into our slice of cheesecake, we looked at each other with a weird expression. I asked her if her's tasted a little off, she replied, "It tastes DISGUSTING!" She then asked me what I thought, and I replied, "It tastes like metallic and wet dog at the same time." We threw those pieces out and tried two other pieces. They had the same flavor. Before throwing the entire cheesecake out, we just happened to taste the part furthest from the center. It tasted fine. We then realized that from the center to the outside edge, half of each piece had a HORRIBLE flavor that can only be described as a coppery, wet dog taste that was VERY unpalatable. 0/10, would NEVER purchase again. Not even worth trying to get our money back, just threw it out. VERY glad neither of us got sick. We have learned our lesson with Member's Mark products. They are at best 50/50 with quality. This cheesecake was LITERALLY 50/50. 50% was okay, 50% was DISGUSTING!

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Aug 7, 2020
Nightowl
5 out of 5 stars review

Repeat Buyer

I have bought this product many times over several years and I have always found it to be the best Cheesecake on the market. You can't beat the price and it is so delicious.. My friends felt the same way when they ate it at my house. Highly recommend.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Sep 25, 2023
JPNewMex
4 out of 5 stars review

Not very cheesy

I've bought this a couple times and love that it is frozen and pre-sliced. It is a good dessert but not really true cheesecake taste. It has a more mild less cheesy taste. If you're not a fan of cheesecake you may actually like this more. I would like to see Sam's offer a more traditional flavor of cheesecake.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Sep 12, 2019
homecook
4 out of 5 stars review

delicious

This was the first store-bought cheesecake my picky husband has liked. It is much better than the bakery case one at Sam’s. It is a bit sweeter than some I’ve tried but the flavor and texture are good. Definitely recommend it. Add fruit topping of your choice and a instant lavish dessert.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Mar 29, 2024
MDP
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Cheesecake

Very good

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Mar 25, 2024
EVE
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Good cheesecake

Really good taste

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Mar 28, 2024
Business Owner
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Excellent cheesecake!

Excellent cheesecake!

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865