Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 9" New York Style Cheesecake, Frozen, 12 slices for
Member's Mark 9" New York Style Cheesecake, Frozen, 12 slices
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars
3,320 ratings954 reviews
  1. 5 stars86% (2,840)
  2. 4 stars7% (242)
  3. 3 stars3% (102)
  4. 2 stars2% (51)
  5. 1 star3% (85)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 61-70 of 954 reviews
Jul 11, 2016
Jessk27
5 out of 5 stars review

SO GOOD

I wasn't going to review this cheesecake at first because every time I like something they seem to discontinue it. But I decided to go ahead and take a chance so I hope they don't take it away. I brought this cheesecake a week ago and I put it in the freezer. Today I decided for dessert we will have cheesecake. I left on the counter so it can thaw out and let me say that this cheesecake is so good I had some strawberries so I pureed them and put that on top and my my my this is the best cheesecake I had in a while. I will be buying this again this week for next Sunday's dessert. It does take a min to thaw out and it says that you should thaw it out in the fridge but I didn't do that and it still turned out to be the best thing I had all week. LOVE IT

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Jan 28, 2024
Will
2 out of 5 stars review

Not a good cheesecake by any means

Cheesecake is supposed to have, at the very least, some tart flavor. This one has almost no flavor whatsoever. They used to sell one in the bakery section that was one of the best store bought cheesecakes you could buy. Why did they discontinued those for this flavorless thing? Better yet why am I forced to give a product I find absolutely disgusting 2 stars?

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Jul 23, 2013
MFWintonio
5 out of 5 stars review

Oooooooh Baby!

Warning : This App Is Auto Capitalizing Every Word I Type. Sorry :( We Always Say We're Going To Buy Stuff Like This, And We Never Do. Today, We Did. With No To Low Expectations We Handed Over Our $9.98 And Headed Home. My Wife Said "I'm Really Picky About My Cheese Cake, But This Is Good, Isn't It? Or Is It Just Tasting Good Because I'm Pregnant? This Is Really Good! I'm Going To Have Another Piece Before I Go To Bed". Well, Folks, We Did, And It Was WORTH IT. Actually, We Didn't, But I Might.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Aug 27, 2022
Wiseguyy007
1 out of 5 stars review

Definitely Not Real Cheesecake

Wow, I brought this home thinking I was gonna binge watch my favorite movies and enjoy three slices of Cheesecake. *NOT* Horrible Product Tasted of Industrial Butter Chemicals. Ahh I tossed the three pieces into the garbage. The rest I will return for a refund. I hate buying Bad Food Products. Lesson Learned

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Jul 1, 2025
Mcva
1 out of 5 stars review

Box sealed, some product missing, plastic bag torn

NEVER HAD THIS HAPPEN in the 40+ years of shopping at Sams.Took this UNOPENED AND SEALED box of cheesecake to a family dinner for dessert. We all watched the box being torn open and were shocked that there were 2 of the 12 slices of cheesecake missing! In addition, the plastic bag surrounding the cheesecake was torn! Call Sams immediately and spoke with a very nice customer service person who gave us a refund online. I will be taking this open box of cheesecake with the 2 slices missing to the store tomorrow. This is an unbelievable experience. We have no idea what may have happened neither did the customer service person. Manufacturer machinery glitch? Very strange.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Mar 2, 2015
theyneedhelp
1 out of 5 stars review

Chemically Laden

This is the cheesecake they replaced the Cheesecake Factory with. Read the ingredients. This thing is chemically laden so of course it is cheaper. You give up quality to get that cheaper price. Tastes like the junk they put in it. Blah! Disappointed in the quality drop over the last few years. Fewer and fewer things for me to buy as they slowly but surely replace the quality products with inferior replacements.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Sep 10, 2013
cfromindiana
5 out of 5 stars review

Wow is an understatement!

This cheesecake is worth every penny! We were leery of this cheesecake because of the low price, but we decided to buy it anyway. It is amazing and the slices are huge! The quality of this cheesecake compares Cheesecake Factory at a much better price. It's so creamy and rich! You can't go wrong with this cheesecake :)

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Mar 1, 2024
Unhappy consumer
3 out of 5 stars review

Price keeps increasing!!!!!!!!!!

Can’t believe Sam’s Club continues to increase the price of this product and literally refuses to EVER put it on sale anymore. I will NEVER purchase this cheesecake again until the price returns to a normal price. Do you seriously think people do not notice and that they don’t remember item prices??????? Why can’t it ever be on sale anymore?????

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Jan 18, 2024
Gladys K
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Little hidden gem in the freezer

I make a really good cheesecake but didn't want to make one. I thought that I would find something in the bakery but was surprised to find a frozen one. Added a can of cherry pie filling on top after thawing, excellent. I would serve this for a dessert with company. Next time in the store I'm grabbing two, one for the freezer and one for now.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865
Sep 25, 2023
Protect And Serve
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Members Mark New York Style 9"Cheesecake:

Outstanding taste, creamy with a good tasting graham cracker texture. Keeps well frozen, it was kept for a month in our 0' freezer before thawing for a party. For under $15.00 you get excellent value and quality taste. We use toppings and or canned whip cream sometimes.

Helpful?7EDHDY5QEL9K13566472865