Great cheesecake- my family’s favorite!

WORST I'VE EVER TASTED!! It doesn't even taste like cheesecake. It tastes like a bland floury paste with a gummy texture. Cheesecake is supposed to have a cream cheese flavor and be rich and decadent. It's absolutely horrible.

I’ve been getting this Cheesecake every Christmas for at least 15 years! It’s been a part of our family tradition and my entire family looks forward to it. I put out crushed pineapple and Cherries to top it but it’s just as good with or without them! It’s heavy, rich and just delicious!

Best cheesecake I’ve ever tasted! It’s rich and tasty. My daughter requests this Cheesecake every year to celebrate her birthday. Our quests always inquire about what restaurant or bakery it was purchased and I’m always happy to reply it came from SAM’s Club freezer case.

This cheesecake is reasonably priced and well worth the money. Great tasting desertt. Will buy it again.

If you like cheesecake from grocery store bakeries then you will like this one. I really like that the cake is pre-cut so you can pull out the number of slices you want at a time. This way you are not wasting any of it if you are the only one in your house eating it like me. Doesn't take long for a slice to thaw maybe 2 hours in the fridge, faster if you left it out.

This is one of the great values at Sam's Club in the freezer section. The taste of the cheesecake will easily make you think it's twice the cost. I really like that it is pre sliced with the paper in-between that really helps you serve it easily. I bought two of these for two separate Mother's Day celebrations and everyone loved them. Would buy again in a heartbeat.

I recently tried the Member’s Mark New York Style Cheesecake and it was really good. The cheesecake is very creamy and smooth, with a rich classic flavor. The graham cracker crust adds a nice crunch and balances the sweetness well. It comes pre-sliced into 12 pieces, which makes it very convenient for serving family or guests. The size is also great for parties or gatherings. I like that it doesn’t contain high fructose corn syrup or artificial flavors. Overall, it’s a delicious and convenient dessert. If you enjoy classic New York cheesecake, this is definitely a good option to keep in the freezer. ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆

been buying this for years (about 3-4 annually) bc it was the closest I could get to New York style being creamy yet firm n crumbly at the same time. may 2026 will be the last time we purchase. now it's just regular cheesecake, but on the soft mushy side. Gotta freeze it for firmness.

Absolutely one of the best cheesecakes if not the best!