I normally love these chocolate protein shakes, but I recently bought 2 cases of them from Sam's Club and THEY ARE DISGUSTING. They smell and taste like some sort of heavy spice, Cumin? Nutmeg? Plus, after I took a big gulp of my first one, my mouth felt slightly numb. I have pulled out several of the drinks out of both cases, and they ALL are like this!! The lid says "Best by Mar27 24 GA 22:46 1 04-197". I hope you fix this because there is something VERY SERIOUSLY WRONG with them!! What REALLY aggravates me is that now I am going to have to put these in the car, go to Sam's club & take them in and wait in line to get a refund! NOT a happy customer any more!

I love drinking these!!! They are amazing, they taste just like chocolate milk. They have amazing ingredients in them so I don’t have to feel guilty drinking them, also have a lot of protein. The texture is very smooth. These are also very good is a milkshake. Overall I love these.

This is hands down the best chocolate nutrition drink I’ve ever had. It’s pricier than the other brand Sam’s carries, but totally worth it. The chocolate is rich in both texture and flavor, and I much prefer drinking it from this plastic bottle over aluminum cans. We even mix it with ice cream for an amazing chocolate milkshake. I really hope Sam’s keeps it in stock. Five stars!

These are my families go to but this last batch is disgusting! Just like the others have mentioned they have a strange nutmeg, gingerbread, eggnog taste and it’s horrible. Not chocolate at all. I will be returning all five cases I just bought. The batch numbers of the bad product I got are BEST BY MAR18 24 GA 00:07 1 04-197

I've been on Warfarin for over 2 years and need to manage my Vitamin K intake. Fairlife Protein drink was the only one I could find that didn't have any Vitamin K content but still met my other nutrition needs. It is sonewhat expensive but it tastes so good; I only wish they made this in strawberry!

What can go wrong with Maxwell House and Fairlife protein drink except to say the Fairlife is scarce at all Sam’s anymore. What is with that? Are you discontinuing it? One can only get it through the mail now at Sam’s and no more Salted Caramel or Vanilla???? What’s up Sam’s? This is one area the real thing beats out your store brand by miles. Please DO NOT stop carrying it.

I’ve been drinking these for quite a while, and they are alway so delicious. Well, I just opened up a new pack & the first bottle had a off, different odor and distinctively tasted like cinnamon. Someone else also made the same comment, so I don’t know if the recipe has changed, or the batch is just “off”.

Fairlife nutrition is amazing. My nutritionist recommended this over premium protein shakes. It has less additives and healthier and taste delicious no after taste. I even like with at room temperature. I wish it was carried in different flavors. It’s hard for them to keep in stock at Sam’s

Best low carb protein shake for anyone on keto. My grandma and I have tried many different protein shakes but this one takes the cake. Fairlife and premier are our favorite, but Fairlife is definitely the best value. The other reviews are right it tastes a lot like chocolate milk without the guilt! If you are hesitant, don’t be! I had chunks in the premier coffee drink it really killed my vibe, but Fairlife has not given me that issue so far and I am very pleased with the quality and quantity of the product. It’s the best!

This tastes soooo much better than Premier Protein! I also like that it’s in a bottle and doesn’t have that aluminum lining that premier has. It tastes like chocolate milk and it’s hard to drink just one! Some of the ingredients are a lil suspect but if I’m rocking with it.