I love these shakes, I’ve been drinking them for years (ever since I started body building). For some reason though the last 4 cases I bought are HORRIBLE. They have this terrible cinnamon flavor. The first 2 cases I bought that tasted like this (a couple weeks ago) I returned. I went back to Sam’s club 2 days ago and they had more out (idk if these were the left overs from the same shipment) but these 2 new cases taste the same!!!

These are my families go to but this last batch is disgusting! Just like the others have mentioned they have a strange nutmeg, gingerbread, eggnog taste and it’s horrible. Not chocolate at all. I will be returning all five cases I just bought. The batch numbers of the bad product I got are BEST BY MAR18 24 GA 00:07 1 04-197

This tastes soooo much better than Premier Protein! I also like that it’s in a bottle and doesn’t have that aluminum lining that premier has. It tastes like chocolate milk and it’s hard to drink just one! Some of the ingredients are a lil suspect but if I’m rocking with it.

Fairlife is the best protein shake I’ve had. It has great nutritionals…30g protein, 2g sugar, 150 calories. It does have “fake” sugars..monkfruit, sucralose, and stevia leaf extract, but it has no aftertaste like so many others. It tastes like chocolate milk!

I used to really love these but since buying them in bulk from Sam's, each bottle is really a hit or miss. Some tastes absolutely wonderful while others tastes absolutely horrid. The ones that are horrid has a taste and smell that is similar to like animal gelatin that hasn't been purified yet. It also sometimes have chunks in them. I've contacted Fairlife before about this but all they did was send me some coupons. I thought on the box it was a money back guaranteed -- not money back guaranteed in coupon form (only five coupons at 55 cents off big jug of their regular or chocolate milk, too)! I ended up getting a couple cases and both cases were like this. I used to really enjoy the Fairlife Nutrition Plan protein shakes but I'm going back to their Core as a treat only and sticking to my powdered protein make-it-yourself kind of shake.

I like the convenience of having them ready made in the fridge. I also like the ultra filtration that produces the sugar, however the price is a little much for a daily drink. I will use them when I go out of town or on vacation. For now I will buy cheap chocolate milk with high sugar and add my own protein powder.

My husband is losing weight using these delicious drinks combined with intermittent fasting with great results. He likes to put the drinks in the freezer for about 30-45 minutes prior to drinking and they freeze to milk shake consistency. They taste like a chocolate shake treat! These high protein drinks seem to be very popular at Sam’s as they sell out quickly so we buy 3-4 packs at a time. They are less expensive than the similar Premier protein drinks with comparable protein grams.

Not sure what is going on but the last 2 cases I bought taste horrible. Can’t even get through the first sip. Almost a mint or cinnamon spice taste. I’ve contacted the company to report and suggest everyone that has the same issue to report it as well. Hopefully they can figure out why there have been several bad reviews about the taste in the last 2 weeks.

My dietician recommended I use the nutrition plan as a means of increasing my protein and help me feel more full. I do like the chocolate, but I would really like a strawberry flavor. My daughter-in-law drinks the strawberry core power, which I tried. Being diabetic, the nutrition plan is better for me. I also drink the milk.

I bought a case from Sam's Club 06/27/2020 because of this product's great reviews, and I was excited to try my first bottle this morning . It was disgusting. I started to gag with the first swallow. The taste and smell is very strange, I hope that Sam's will let me return. I am going back to Slim Fast with 20 gr of protein.