I've been buying these smaller sized pop-up foil sheets from Sam's for years, in addition to the lager sized pop-up foil sheets (I usually keep one of each size in my kitchen at all times). Recently (the last two boxes I've purchased of the smaller size) the quality has gone downhill in terms of being able to dispense these from the pop-up box one at a time without the sheets tearing and/or 3-4 of the sheets coming out when attempting to just dispense one sheet (which is literally the entire point of buying foil like this versus on a roll-to be able to dispense one sheet at a time and use only the amount of foil you need for the task at hand). basically I attempt to pull out one sheet and end up with like 3.25 sheets coming out instead. I've continued to purchase the larger sized foil pop-up sheets since they do not seem to have this same issue, but until Sam's deals with their quality control situation with these smaller pop-up foil sheets I'll no longer purchase them. it sounds like others are experiencing the exact same issue too, based on the more recent reviews, so the issue must be on the manufacturing side. too bad - I kind of loved these little ones back when they were still usable and preferred them to the larger sheets; I used to use the little ones for nearly everything (from being just the right size to wrap a single slice of leftover pizza to being exactly the right size to wrap up a small ear of corn to go onto the grill, to being exactly enough foil to use for cooking in the air fryer, to being exactly the right amount of foil to wrap one piece of meat to bake in the oven, or exactly enough full to cover a small plate of leftovers, and the list goes on).

Way too thin, so much so sheets often rip just taking them out of the box!! Also since so thin and lightweight, it gets sucked up by the air fryer (basket version) on sides/where no food is on it.. normally a member's mark product fan but, definitely not a fan of this one, i ended up having to reorder regular heavy duty reynolds roll and cut sheets up myself..

Sheets are a bit thin, but are perfect for wrapping left overs into smaller portions. Saves a lot of wasted foil and fridge space. Instead of putting half of an XL pizza in one big wrap of rolled foil (or dry out in the box in the fridge), you can store a slice or two in each sheet and take what you need later for a snack or meal. Works well for other things besides pizza too :).

I was a little disappointed with these foil sheets. The thickness was fine and sizing was accurat. My issues is trying to dispense these foil sheets while in service. Even though they are stacked to be eaisily dispensed, they would still tear out of the the box. Slowly dispensing these or even pre dispensing helped, but it is inefficient for my operation.

This Member's Mark foil sheets are extremely disappointing! Just touching it and it tears--simply terrible. It's almost as bad as papier-mâché. Thin, flimsy, poor quality, and just plain unusable. I'm fairly reasonable in my assessment of products, so now I'm suspicious of all these 5-star reviews from other users. Did I get faulty product, or are they just a lot more lenient than I am?

First time buying. Convenient.

I purchase these they are too thin easy to tear

Absolutely terrible product. The foil is so thin it rips when you try to use it.

They're not as sturdy as they used to be. Disappointing.

These are great. Perfect thickness for use in the air fryer. The value is there. The dispenser is very easy to use too. Would buy again.