I bought the three tomato sauces Sam's Club carries (three that I could see). The Member's Mark won hands down. Yes it's an anecdotal taste test I conducted, but everything, color, seasoning, and flavor were better. The Member's Mark tasted the most natural and had the brightest color. In my experience it's rare when the "store" brands are actually better. Well, it's true this time. I also did a tomato paste taste test about a year ago. That one was more difficult to determine because there was much less difference between the six pastes I tested. This one surprised me as the big brand (starts with an "H") was actually the least preferred. In my opinion, for tomato sauce there's no reason to buy anything else, buy the Member's Mark.

I've been using this sauce for years and the product is excellent. Nice and bright flavor. The shipping on this last order was horrible, however. The case packaging arrived completely cut open and 4 cans were severely dented, one of which looked like it had been driven over by a forklift. All of this "mess" was stuffed back together and then wrapped in packing paper, so they fully knew exactly what they were sending me. Why on Earth would they ship me a clearly opened and badly damaged case? Of course I'm not keeping it.

I do the Paleo food plan and I like this tomato sauce because it has no added sugars. I add 2 tsp. of Splenda and 1 tsp. Italian Seasoning to it and microwave for 2 minutes. Then let it sit for a few minutes. My husband says he likes it too. I use it to make meat loaf and to pour over meatballs.

This makes a good dipping sauce for breadsticks, with just a little tweak to the seasoning. Unfortunately the case I bought had been taped over, so I didn't notice until later that a bunch of the cans inside had been crushed. It should have been written off as breakage. Instead, I got stuck with damaged goods.

Used to be a brand name

Cans were packed dented.

This sauce was amazing until recently. They have definitely changed the recipe as it is drastically different . Horrible flavor now that cannot be fixed or adjusted by any means. It ruined several meals now. I will no longer be purchasing.

Been buying Hunts Tomato sauce for more than 50 years. I like Sams so bought a case of the members Mark tomato sauce. I've opened up a can of Hunts earlier in the morning. Just opened up the members Mark and disgusting. Does not have the fresh tomato a smell like any Hunts. products do. Very dark red. Almost blackish. Thinking about throwing the whole case of away. It's just awful smelling. And it's fresh too I just got it from Sam's guess I'm used to the pretty red color of Hunts and The wonderful aroma. I actually drank a little bit left in the can this morning of the Hunts and it was so delicious

Really thought it was good. Got a great flavor and sauce is a little thicker than other brands I’ve tried. Will definitely be ordering more!

Full-flavored with excellent thickness, this tomato sauce is easily as good as any we’ve had, even those that cost twice as much.