I previously rated this PB a 5. Great taste, price, etc. the best part was this natural PB didn’t separate. Unfortunately, the last few jars I bought, I find it separates and the oil sits on top. Loved it before but probably won’t buy it in the future.

I have been buying this peanut regularly for about four years and the quality has been consistent. I have never experienced it being runny or oily that some reviewers report. Also, if you do not know what "natural" means on a label, it means nothing artificial was added during processing and the product was minimally processed. Palm Oil and sugar are natural ingredients. They are not artificial. If you want to know what's in it read the ingredient list. I do not add sugar to anything or eat candy, ice cream, etc. but I will say that 3 grams of sugar in a serving (2 Tbsp) is not a lot. Also palm oil is MUCH healthier than the hydrogenated oils that you will find in Skippy and Jif. If there is no oil added to peanut butter it can be very hard to stir.

We are a Jif family through and through. My warehouse doesn’t carry Jif in store so I figured I’d take a chance on these. For the price it wasn’t much of a risk. I am SO glad I did. We like this PB better than Jif and I can’t believe I’m saying that. My youngest son will decide he doesn’t like something without even trying it just because it’s different from what he’s used to, so I put this peanut butter in an empty Jif container and he hasn’t said a word.

Natural peanut butter should be just that! Ingredients should be: ground peanuts and nothing more. Added oil means the good peanut oil was removed and sold separately and if we want sweet peanut butter we can add our own honey, not the added sugar, which is probably refined. Still a step above Jif, Skippy, Peter Pan, etc. who use hydrogenated oils.

No Stir. Says so on the label. This peanut butter appears to be half vegetable oil. I made a video. When you open the jar, there is almost an inch of oil on top. After stirring for a while, the peanut butter is creamy, all right, it has the texture of maple syrup. Put it on a slice of bread or a tortilla and it just runs off. The video doesn't matter since this website either doesn't allow the uploading of videos, or the process is secret. Clicking on steps 2 and 3 below have no effect.

The peanut butter is really greasy. I am not eating it . I have 2 dogs I fix pnbutter with cracker every night. The oil soaks into cracker immediately. This brand is terrible. One dog don't will not eat it. The other dog gradually eats it . Be glad when Jiff is back.

My mistake in purchasing... I didn’t read the label close enough to learn this is a mixture of oil, sugar and peanuts. When shopping I entered “Peanut Butter” not thinking the choices would include non-peanut butter. This tastes awful and is not the healthy product I thought I had ordered.

I’ve been using jiff forever so, when the recall happened, I had an unopened 2 pack that had to go back to Sam’s. Based on some if the reviews, I decided to give the member’s mark brand a try. It’s very tasty, spreads easily, and a bit less money to buy. I’m really glad there’s an alternative to jiff at Sam’s!

I was really weary buying a store brand but I also did not want to make another stop so I took the chance. Peanut butter is a go to snack for me - plain, mixed with honey, on crackers, celery - i could go on but I am sure you get the idea. I did not want something that tasted stale, or that I had to stir because the oil separated (sorry that is just ewww) and I wanted a fresh taste. This gave me all that and at a very competitive price - Will be our family's new regular brand

I was interested in this product until I, too, read the ingredients. I will stick with the truly natural product where there's just peanuts and salt, nothing else. I will put up with having to stir in the peanut oil before putting it into the refrigerator and after that no oil separation.