The only reason for the low star is that on the label it brags to be "no stir" however everything I use it I find myself having to stir the peanut butter because the oils seep to the top. One time it happened within 30 minutes between two sandwiches. Taste is good and if you don't mind stirring it is a good peanut butter.

My husband is Mr. Peanut Butter - an *authority." He declares this to be the BEST. AND - it's natural but not all separated and oily and yucky. Doubts you'll find better at such a good price. (Our doggo loves it as well, and she's a picky lil' brat.)

I use a hand mixer to blend/incorporate the oils that all "natural" peanut butters have on the surface. After doing so with this brand, this stuff is literally pourable at room temperature. I've never seen this in the numerous "natural" peanut butters I've purchased over the years. It's only redeeming quality is the taste but I won't be purchasing this stuff again due to its room temperature ketchup like viscosity.

Its 12 cents cheaper where I live right now to buy 2 of the 40 oz Walmart's Natural Peanut butter. For this being a Sam's product it should be a lower price than Walmart. I also believe they shrunk the jars as these used to be 48oz now they are 40oz. This one has added sugar and palm oil. Walmart's has 1g less added sugar than this one while still having Palm oil. The natural label is misleading in this case because Palm oil is not natural. If ingredients are important to you this is not the peanut butter for you.

My family has been using this PB exclusively for several years now. We are huge PB lovers and this stuff is amazing! Whether its for baking, pb&j's, pb & banana smoothies, on top of waffles, etc. it's just soooo good! And best of all, the ingredients are much healthier than typical PB but without that weird texture or oily soupy stuff on top. My parents love it, my sister and her family love it, and I've even turned die hard fans of "other" popular brands on to it.

As a life-long Jif devotee, I'll admit I was skeptical of a "generic" peanut butter. This Members Mark PB is better than Jif and the price can't be beat. The flavor is great, not too sugary and just the right balance of salt and creaminess. This is our go-to brand of PB now and I have no reason to go back to Jif. Thanks Sam's Club!

When you first open it the PB is really runny, when you get to the bottom it is so stiff you can hardly get it out of the jar. So with the second jar, I have tried to stir it and that's just messy. It was an okay substitute when you couldn't get Jiff but I won't be purchasing this again unless I have no choice.

The difference between peanut butter and peanut butter spread..... peanut butter needs to be 90 percent peanuts and peanut butter SPREAD only needs to be only 60 percent peanuts. What else do they put in it? Palm oil and they say CANE SUGAR.... they act like it's something special..... IT'S SUGAR .....why do they need to put sugar in peanut butter at all????? DON'T EVER BUY PEANUT BUTTER SPREAD

Yes, this is a peanut butter spread, but natural or no stir? NOT I've had to stir this stuff EVERY time I opened it. I should have paid more attention to the ingredients, sugar and palm oil do not make a natural peanut butter. Bought it once, dealing with it, but will NOT buy again.

This is the best pb I've ever had. The taste is phenomenal! Love that it spreads so easily without tearing bread. It has to be stirred periodically but no big deal. We also love it because it's so much easier to get our dog to take her pills. It doesn't stick to one's mouth like other brands. Again, the flavor is fantastic!!