Good quality and tasty

I specifically purchased this product because the labeling indicated no stir. Imagine my surprise when I opened a jar only to discover at least an inch of oil covering the pb. Due to the height of the jar it was impossible to reincorporate the oil to the very bottom without removing the contents into a mixing bowl then transferring the incorporated product back to the jar, a messy procedure resulting in some loss of product. For the record, the product was transported directly to my residence and promptly placed in a temperature controlled pantry. 2nd jar was donated to a food bank with a post it note indicating it isn't NO STIR.

OK so let me be real here, I am a life long Jif fan and would never consider another brand but since the Jif recall I had to return my peanut butter & needed a replacement and literally this is the only peanut butte that was left in the store so since I eat peanut butter every day I bought it and I am so glad I did ! OMG it is better than Jif ! Less, salt, fat and creamier and yummier! I am switching to this brand from now on and best of all t is a better value !

I was disappointed at first to lose the option of Skippy Natural that Sam's used to carry. But this really has been a pretty decent alternative. A little thicker, maybe not quite as good of flavor, but overall, I'm satisfied. Also, 10 to 20 calories less than some peanut butter per 32g serving. If that sort of thing matters to you.

While shopping at Sam's I notice a new Peanut Butter at a good price. I bought it and brought it home. It reminded me of the old Oxhart Creamy Peanut Butter from my youth. I tried it the first time and thought, it's a little different I'll have to get use to it. The second time I tried it, I thought, it doesn't have much peanut butter taste. My wife tried it and she hated it. I tired to like it having it two more times. The last time, I looked for the second jar of it and put them together for return to the store. It just doesn't have much peanut butter flavor. I wouldn't recommend this peanut butter to anyone who has ever tasted, Peanut Butter!!

I used to buy this, believing it was a better coice than the peanut butter that has a lot of added sugar and other ingredients. However, its right there on the front label, "Peanut Butter SPREAD". That extra word makes all the difference. Peanut butter should be simply peanuts and salt, maybe honey and sugar. This has Palm oil. If you are under the illusion that this is a "healthier" option then think again.

I was excited to see that Sam's was selling "natural" Peanut Butter in our store...until... I read the ingredients! "Natural" Peanut Butter doe NOT have Sugar added and does NOT have any Oil Added. Peanuts have plenty of natural oil and sugars in them already....naturally. I am Totally DISAPPOINTED!

We have bought this product before and we liked it. However this purchase was horrible. So much oil that it was hard to stir without it sloshing out of the container. I originally thought we got a bad one so I opened the other jar and it was the same. Did you change the recipe or just a heavy handed oil distributor?

We are a Jif family through and through. My warehouse doesn't carry Jif in store so I figured I'd take a chance on these. For the price it wasn't much of a risk. I am SO glad I did. We like this PB better than Jif and I can't believe I'm saying that. My youngest son will decide he doesn't like something without even trying it just because it's different from what he's used to, so I put this peanut butter in an empty Jif container and he hasn't said a word.

This is not the best example of “natural” peanut butter. Natural peanut butter is made with 100% peanuts and nothing else other than a little salt. There is no added sugar or an alternate oil. Peanut oil is a healthy nut oil and that has been removed and a different oil has been added. Adding sugar to peanut butter is not only unnecessary but actually reduces the flavor of peanuts, which several other reviewers have noted. My husband purchased this peanut butter on his last trip to Sams Club without reading the ingredients, based on the word “natural” on the label. He was very disappointed when he tasted it. Members Mark, Sams Clubs house brand, has many good products. Unfortunately we do not feel this is one of them.