Do not buy this peanut butter! It taste like plastic spread with a hint of peanut. Last but not least, never buy anything that is suppose to be butter that says “spread”. Zero stars.

We really like this peanut butter. We have had a batch or 2 that the oil did separate but we mix into recipes and not on sandwiches, so it still works.

Maybe the best Natural Peanut Butter (non flavored) available. Take the challenge - post your opinion. If you do not agree after opening first jar - donate unopened 2nd jar to your Food Bank. The downside and why I don't give it 5 stars is: Sam's does not make this available in all stores. In my market- only 2 out of 5 show it available in stores. I think they should offer free "to store" shipping when a product is available and they choose not to have at all stores. I would love Sam's (not Ai) to explain.

I previously rated this PB a 5. Great taste, price, etc. the best part was this natural PB didn’t separate. Unfortunately, the last few jars I bought, I find it separates and the oil sits on top. Loved it before but probably won’t buy it in the future.

No Stir? Every time I opened the jar I had to stir this peanut butter spread. I even tried mixing it up in my stand mixer then separating it into smaller jars. Whether it was week or just a day, I had to stir before use. The taste is acceptable, but it's messy and inconvenient. I won't be purchasing this product again.

I have been buying Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk. for a very long time. We love it, well loved it anyways. The last few months we have been getting crap products. It started with one that was half oil. Returned that one. This last shipment they have been thinner than usual. I do not know if it is a quality control issue or they are sitting in a hat warehouse and have separated. Could be a combination of both but I think it is a QC issue. EIther way we are going back to the Aldi brand peanut butter. What a shame.

Great product

Love this peanut butter!

This was delicious

Easy to spread