I have always been a Jif peanut butter eater. Because the Member's Mark peanut butter why was $2 cheaper for 2 jars I decided to try it. I don't know what the difference is it is very close but I felt like it was just a little bit better than Jif.

Like and appreciate most MM products but this is an absolute dud. Oil is separating from the "spread". Not peanut butter, not good. It's cheap, there's a reason.

This peanut butter is my favorite! After the recall with jif brand I have been looking for a new pb that my whole family would love. This one is so good and the price is amazing and you get two for that price. Highly recommend!

This is the best peanut butter in the universe!!! Not only is it 5 star but the price is ridiculously low. LOL watch - after this review the price will be $1 more xo.

So glad I tried Sam’s brand. It’s delicious and so much better than JIF. Just automatically always bought JIF. And was stuck with two large jars when it was recalled. This is outstanding peanut butter.

We really like this peanut butter. We have had a batch or 2 that the oil did separate but we mix into recipes and not on sandwiches, so it still works.

This is a great value for peanut butter. We go through a lot of peanut butter and this is one of my favorites. It isn't too sweet, and is very smooth.

I love this peanut butter because it's ingredients are roasted peanuts, sugar, palm oil and sea salt. To me that says it's simple ingredients that I don't have to have a dictionary to figure out what that is. It's another great Member's Mark brand.

Extra creamy and no hassle of mixing the oil like other natural peanut butter. The flavor is not too salty or sweet. The texture is smooth and not grainy.

The taste is really good, but like most natural peanut butters, you’ll do better with a silicone spatula or spoon than a knife to get it out of the jar and on to your bread/celery/cracker. Probably needs to be kept in the fridge.