Those 5 star reviews must be paid! You have to literally stir it every time! Not natural flavor...

It separated with oil on top and is not very tasty. Had to throw both jars away -noone would eat.

The peanut butter is to oily you have to stir it every time you use it.

One of the few times I was highly disappointed with having chosen a Member's Mark brand product.

Natural peanut butter is just peanuts or peanuts and salt. This has palm oil and sugar in it.

Horrible taste and aftertaste and texture. Palm oil and sugar instead of peanut taste.

The flavor is not great and it's got too much oil.

This peanut butter is terrible. Bring back the 6lb cans of Peter Pan.