We buy this peanut butter all the time, but the most recent batch was gross! I don't know what was wrong with it but it smelled weird and was just off. I threw both jars in the trash. Not sure I'm willing to give it another try it was so bad.

Idk what they changed. It's a runny pudding consistency. Oil puddles with separation. Somehow slimey and sticky at the same time. New double pack, and both went in the trash. Will not purchase again.

It tasted fine, but the consistency was not there. The oil tended to move to the top. Oily on top, hard to stir on the bottom. Does not keep well. I ended up disposing of the 2nd jar soon after opening it. It was a mess.

I bought a 2 pack of this peanut butter like substance and had to constantly stir it every time I used it to keep from getting a knife-full and it was rather flavorless also.

The Members Mark peanut butter that I bought is oily and messy. I can pour this peanut butter from the jar. It tastes ok but I don't like it and I plan to throw it away and get some more Jif

This is a delicious peanut butter, but it is advertised as no stir. That is not true. Unless you just pour off the oil, it definitely needs to be stirred.

this has to be the sorriest peanut butter out there l opened it pull the paper seal off and spilled oil all over my counter DO NOT BUY THIS UNLESS YOU NEED COOKING OIL INSTEAD OF PEANUT BUTTER

Bring back Jif! I purchased two jars hoping that it would be a quality product. There was enough oil to fill my car. Taste was poor and so greasy and tasteless that I discarded both jars. Waste of money and, obviously, I will not purchase again.

What a blatant FRAUD to call this "natural" peanut butter when it has unhealthy SUGAR & PALM OIL (an unsustainable destroyer of ecosystems). Shame on Sam's Club!

This product is very disappointing as it doesn't taste much like peanut butter and is extremely oily. Please bring back Skippy Natural Peanut Butter, Member's Mark really missed the mark on this one.