This is without a doubt the best tasting and easiest to spread peanut butter I have consumed in over 50 years. And dirt cheap at Sam's. Try it you will love it.

Love this peanut butter. It's on the oily side, so you do have to stir it, but that's exactly how I like it, and why I prefer this Member's Mark brand. Good stuff!

This peanut butter has great taste and it's smooth. However, I'm not a fan of the added sugar and palm oil, but if I run out of my regular PB, this is my top substitute!

It says no stir, but the oil rises to the top and if you don't stir it, by the time you get to the bottom of the jar, the peanut butter is the consistency of play dough. I have to stir it, and it is difficult to get the oil mixed back in.

I usually don’t buy store brand anything but decided to give this a try. First it’s absolutely delicious, second it has very few ingredients. I was sincerely surprised. So I just have to say kudos.

The Last jar had no oil and was dry. Usually there’s a layer of oil on top that needs to be stirred. This is not the same product . Did you change the recipe? Was 5 stars before.

Before 2023 the taste was creamy and bold. But they must have changed vendors and the taste is not the same. It used to taste like Skippy natural, now it tastes like JIF.

This is not an “all natural” peanut butter. It contains just as much sugar as a National brand, and it contains palm shortening. It has a good flavor, but the labeling is a bit misleading.

Lots of oil, you will definately need to stir this peanutbutter... over and over and over. Overall a good taste, but I cant get past having to stir the peanutbutter every use for the first 2/3s of the jar.

It was another famous peanut butter I was after and bought Members Mark instead. Natural, no stir and no hydrogenated oil. It’s cheaper and more important, it tastes better! Try It!