Very oily, almost soupy and needs to be stirred. Just get a name brand peanut butter because members mark has not come close.

Natural in peanut butter lingo means the ingredient list should read Peanuts & Salt, Sam's. Nothing else.

Thought it was crunchy. Very deceiving by the pic. Now I'm stuck with two of them and it's very oily.

This is the best peanut butter I have ever eaten. I bought a two pack and tried then went back and bought more.

I can’t get past the 1/2 inch of oil on top. So much for “no stir”. This is awful and there is no way to stir it without taking it all out of the jar.

If you had blindfolded me and ask which one was jif,I don't think I could separate member's mark and JIF. The only notable difference to me, was JIF was slightly creamery and smoother, with rising prices I would select the cheaper one everytime.

I purchased the Members Mark peanut butter after I ran out of the competitor’s brand. So glad I did because I really like the taste. Real peanut taste and not so sweet. Great product.

This peanut butter is very smooth so it is easy to spread on bread. It's slightly sweet as it has some sugar in it. The price is also friendly to the wallet.

This peanut butter used to be awesome. It used to truly be no stir. Something changed and now it's all oily on top and you definitely have to stir. The flavor is still good but I really miss the old kind.

I like the product except for the stirring. This is not "no stir." There is oil/liqued on top of the peanut butter, and has to be stirred every time you use it. It's a good product but it's not "no stir."