I grew up eating only Jif peanut butter...but it has changed over the years and is not the Jif I knew and loved.....it's almost fake, too creamy and well, I don't know what happened, but it is not the same....I will stick to roasting and grinding my own peanuts without all the added oils....

We love our Jif but what’s going on with the inconsistent consistency? Bought some in February that was drier than usual. Next jar is very runny. We buy the 2-pack so I’m pretty sure the next jar will be the same. My husband won’t eat it but I’m trying to eat it. Is there a problem we should know about?

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] There are some things that I don’t skimp on and peanut butter is one of them. We have tried others, but always come back to Jif. Jif has a delicious peanut butter flavor and it’s blended so smoothly that it goes on easily over bread. Definitely a family favorite that I count on for dips, spreads, and baking.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] JIF peanut butter is superior to all other brands. The creamy texture makes this very easy to spread and the flavor is great! Packaging is great and this size in particular is a great size to keep on hand when you have a smaller pantry/space.

Jif creamy as it is my favorite although I also pickup a crunchy now and then too. I love the Jif TV commercial about Charlie the imaginary friend. WELL DONE creative team. My son had an imaginary friend growing up and it brought back wonderful memories. Thank you!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Jif Peanut Butter is the best! It has always been a staple peanut butter in my house. I especially love the Creamy Peanut Butter. It’s not too rich and absolutely delicious. Would recommend to anyone!

I was shocked at how many reviews said it was oily. I don't know if they just had an old batch or what. But I have never experienced that with any JIF peanut butter and we eat a lot of it in my house. I love the flavor and texture. I also appreciate that they use palm oil instead of rapeseed or canola oil which significantly changes the flavor of things.

I made my traditional peanut blossom cookies for the holiday. My cookie dough was way too soft even when chilled. My cookies spread too much. Not sure what you changed but the consistency of my brand new jar is way softer or looser than I recall. Dissatisfied with how my cookies turned out.

I just finished a jar I had for several months-good peanut flavor, perfect salt, not greasy. Bought another cause so excited to get another great jar- sadly it was weak peanut flavor, lacking enough salt, and overly greasy. I used to talk about Jif, but can't Now.

I have bought JIF peanut butter (creamy) my whole adult life n Im 47. My husband LOVES peanut butter n refuses 2 eat any other brand. My 3 kids have been raised on it. I typically buy the large tubs or the large jars. So these r just a few reasons 1 jar won't change my opinion on JIF. My current jar is so thin that it barely stays on the knife from the jar 2 the bread. Iv never found oil settled on top of a jar of JIF peanut butter. So Im baffled with this jar. This is a 48oz jar n it is stirred with each use. The flavor does seem 2 be a bit bland but we have used it regardless. So Im just curious if there could b some explanation on y this has happened or did I just get the 1 jar with a glitch lol. I will continue 2 buy JIF, just a curious fan. I would have posted a video if I had thought 2 do this review sooner. But since the jar is almost empty, it would b useless. We have 2 more 48oz jars in the pantry so I did open 1 of them 2 check the consistency n it's normal. P.S the 3 stars rating is 4 the 1 specific jar. My overall rating of JIF in general is definitely 5 stars!