I have been buying Jif for years and I have never seen oil on top of the peanut butter when I took the lid off. It is so thin that it is hard to put on crackers without it trying to fall off. It has an oily taste and does not taste like real peanut butter.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] It’s creamy and it’s delicious, it’s the brand we have been using since I was a kid. The flavor is so good and it has the perfect amount of sweetness. The way it spreads on bread is the best, it’s also a great snack when you need a quick energy boost, it’s delicious and nutritious and very trusted

I’ve been buying Jif creamy peanut butter for as long as I can remember. However the last several times I’ve purchased Jif creamy peanut butter it has been runny. It used to be like a soft solid which I would scoop it with a spoon, now it is so runny it literally runs off the spoon like a liquid. I’m not sure what changed but it is not the same and not good any more.

I bought some Jif that is my favorite brand but after having a PBJ one evening I suffered severe stomach cramps and diarrhea. You've changed something and for the worse. Rap seed , cotton seed and palm kernel oils are not healthy. I'm going to find another brand.

I bought the large two-pack a few months ago and it seems like the recipe has been changed. It is really runny, like it melted and drips off the bread. Jif has been my favorite peanut butter since I was a kid and I won't eat other peanut butter, but this new batch is not good. I am disappointed, it's too expensive to be this bad. I hope they go back to the old recipe.

I promised myself when I started buying peanut butter, it would only be Jif! I've kept that promise! It's the BEST! No other compares to Jif. I buy the double pack and it's always on my counter. My doggie loves it too. She waits for her taste every time she hears the jar open.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I used this peanut butter to make some cookies. It made some very tasty peanut butter cookies. It is very smooth and has the right amount of saltiness to it. We also used it to make a grilled peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It spreads on the bread like butter and did not tear the bread at all. It has the right amount of thickness for us.

I came here to find out if the recipe had changed because the jar I’m eating right now is different. Oil separation (just a little) which I’ve never seen and I’ve been eating Jif for over 50 years. The texture is lighter and creamier, not the normal thick, smooth PB I’ve loved all my life. Not sure what’s going on but seeing others with similar complaints. Fix Jif, please!

Hi, my 18 year has eaten 3-5 Jiff Creamy PBJ sandwiches daily his whole life. Suddenly this week he is complaining that it tastes weird. He has tried the peanut butter alone numerous times and numerous jars and it still tastes weird. Did you change the recipe!

Great Peanut Butter but with a problem at this time that I am hopeful will be corrected soon. I do trust this company and its product and hope they get things corrected soon and I will buy this Peanut Butter again soon, I hope. I am returning four 28oz jars of this peanut butter to my local store for a full refund because of the recall, as instructed by the stores costumer service. Anyone that has any of this peanut butter that is on the recall list should take it back to their store and hopefully they will give you a refund.