Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Kidde 10-Year Photoelectric Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm, Model P3010K for
Kidde 10-Year Photoelectric Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm, Model P3010K
3.4 out of 5 stars
stars224 ratings147 reviews
  1. 5 stars54% (122)
  2. 4 stars4% (10)
  3. 3 stars2% (5)
  4. 2 stars7% (16)
  5. 1 star32% (71)
Write a review
Sort by |
Showing 71-80 of 147 reviews
Aug 27, 2021
Lauren
1 out of 5 stars review

Fake Dual Smoke/CO Detectors

I had a smoke/carbon monoxide (CO) combo detector like this in my new house. Within 1 year the CO alarm went off, and I had to call 911. The firemen told me that it had malfunctioned. In fact, if it really was a CO issue and enough CO had built up to reach the ceiling to set off the alarm, I would be dead! A CO detector should be plugged into an outlet down near the floor. Why are they still approved to make this kind of fake dual detector? If you don't believe the firemen or me, check it out online for yourself. Be safe!

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
reply from Kidde Expert

Hello. That is not true. Carbon monoxide is nearly the same weight as air and freely mixes with air. If anything, carbon monoxide is usually slightly lighter than air depending on the temperature and weight of the gases in the house. But usually carbon monoxide follows the air flow in the house and can be detected at any height. . Call us with the alarm in hand at 1-800-880-6788 so we can figure out what is going on and how we can help you.

Aug 29, 2024
Chirpingevery30
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible defective alarm

Had a false alarm at 530 am during a storm the cut out the power at the same time…this model is faulty and they have to know this….i’ve never had a random false fire alarm like how this went off. Now it’s chirping every 30 seconds even after cleaning it There’s no easy way to find how to stop the chirping. Horrible product that they need to recall. My alsrms are only 2 yrs old

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
Feb 4, 2025
CRS725
1 out of 5 stars review

Waste of Money-Continous false alarms

I bought 2 of these for my home in August 2024. They worked fine for about 60 days then they both began to go off unexpectedly. At first I was concerned that a fire or CO2 event was occurring but after about a week of false alarms I uninstalled both. The alarms would go off for about 10 seconds then would go quite. My other alarms, not by Kidde, did not detect any issues. I consider this a waste of resources and will not but a product from this company again!

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
Dec 20, 2021
Kathy
1 out of 5 stars review

did not work

Purchased in either October or November and finally got it mounted about two weeks ago - read instructions carefully & the alarm beeped when attaching it to the base, I even did the monthly test prior to mounting in main room with gas fireplace. Two days ago someone put two or three very large pine cones in the unvented (damper closed) gas fireplace. The room was FULL to choking point with billowing smoke. black clouds of smoke obscured the smoke alarm completely, yet it never made even a chirp. Kidde has always had an excellent reputation in alarms & extinguishers, yet in this instance (at least on this particular alarm) it failed completely. I have a lot of Kidde extinguishers, and they consistently rate high. I was very surprised, and double checked - no where in the instructions does it say anything other than "smoke" alarm. I know some alarms work on heat, the alarm was not in an area of heat, but if it is supposed to recognize smoke, this particular alarm did not.

Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
Nov 19, 2024
Lee1
1 out of 5 stars review

Really disappointed

Moderately reduced unwanted alarms in kitchen but failed after 3 years with unstoppable alarm, requiring destruction of the unit. Vacuuming failed. Also, pause and test on the same button was a horrible idea! Pausing frequently turned into testing!

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
May 27, 2022
Ilia
1 out of 5 stars review

False alarm

Completely new units installed in a clean house only 2 months ago, no painting or dust issues. Installed following recommendations on location. Started going off at 12:30am with no obvious cause. There is no dust in the air (two air filters in the room) and no insects. If it goes off again will have to replace all units as I can't trust them.

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
reply from Kidde Product Support

Hello. Before you replace the units, call us with that unit going off in hand so we can help you figure out why this keeps happening and get this resolved for you. We can help you figure out what is going on.

Apr 18, 2024
msr in MA
1 out of 5 stars review

abysmal performance

I bought one which lasted a bit under a year. Kidde sent me a free replacement at the start of January 2024. Now, 3 months later, that alarm is signaling that's it malfunctioning. This product should not be on the shelves out there. "Worry-free" is laughable. Now I won't even bother to ask for a 3rd. What waste of my money.

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
Aug 22, 2022
LPSJ
1 out of 5 stars review

False alarms

We originally had these installed in 2019 throughout the house. Not even a year later, the alarms started randomly going off, and the company who installed them removed all of them and placed brand new ones again. Now 2 years later, the alarms are randomly going off without any trigger. I can see that we are not the only ones who have experienced this issue. I would like some assistance with these faulty alarms.

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
reply from Kidde Product Support

Hello. False alarms are most commonly caused by something interfering with the sensor. To clean, hold the unit by its edge and thoroughly blow through the gap on the side of the unit with compressed air (like keyboard cleaner). We recommend cleaning out all of your smoke alarms at least every 6 months to a year and at this point we would recommend cleaning out all of your other alarms as well as a preventative. Some of your alarms may be in one the locations to avoid listed in the owner's manual. This would especially include alarms being installed within 3 ft (.9m) of a forced air supply ducts used for heating or cooling, ceiling or whole house ventilating fans, or other high air flow areas. We recommend that alarms not be installed near vents, flues, chimneys, or fans. We recommend that alarms not be installed near doors or windows near areas directly exposed to the weather. We strongly recommend not to install these alarms in garages, attics, and crawl spaces as you will get temperatures, dust, insects, and chemicals that can cause nuisance alarms. Try cleaning out the alarms. If you have the issue again, call us with that alarm in hand at 1-800-880-6788 so we can get this resolved for you.

May 10, 2023
Angry Mom
1 out of 5 stars review

Alarms died within 4 years!

I installed two of these in 2019, one in the kitchen and one in the living room. We had a major issue with the toaster tonight which resulted in the kitchen filling with DENSE smoke, overflowing into the living room, and there wasn't a peep out of either smoke detector!!! They are totally dead; I tried hitting the test button after triaging the emergency situation first, and they didn't respond to that either. Who knows when they actually died (terrifying to think we've been so vulnerable for so long)... but they should have had 6 years left in them! The false sense of security these provide is nightmarish! I will stick to the replaceable-battery kind in the future. Would rather have them chirp in the middle of the night due to a low battery, then have my whole house burn down because these nonsense detectors don't live up to their promise!!

Review from Kidde
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646
reply from Kidde Product Support

Hello. Please call us at 1-800-880-6788 with the alarms in hand. We do stand behind our products and we are happy to troubleshoot and figure out what is going on and get an issue resolved. We want to find out more.

Dec 14, 2019
Spider
5 out of 5 stars review

So far, so good!

Took a little longer to get the products delivered than we thought, but once they arrived, they fit perfectly in the space where the old detectors were. So far so good. We like the idea that we won’t have to change the batteries twice a year like we had been.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?333NAE07A5W04787110646