We are trying these because the Member's Mark Wipes are no longer available. We have been using Member's Mark wipes for years and have had no complaints (aside from the occasional pack drying out when a child tears the plastic a bit too enthusiastically). When comparing them side by side... I have never had a Member's Mark wipe rip while removing from the package. One in three Cottonelle wipes will have a giant flap ripped through the middle, even while being careful. An unfolded Member's Mark wipe can be used confidently for several swipes, folded, swipe again, fold again if you're feeling bold for a final swipe, and then discard. An unfolded Cottonelle wipe will rip on the first swipe, shred itself into pills and wrap around any hairs painfully on the second or third gentle swipe. Are the Cottonelle wipes better than dry paper alone? As long as you have enough of them, yes. I would not be confident about being able to finish a cleaning job with just one or two. Have I checked for alternatives? Yes. They are unpleasant to use and do not inspire confidence in their results. I should not be finding lumps of shredded wipes after cleaning. My kids are unable to pull a single sheet out without it ripping in the process. They fall apart almost immediately. Included pics are from a freshly opened Cottonelle pack and one of the last two wipes left in my MM pack.

These wipes are basically wet tissue paper. They tear extremely easily just taking them out of the package, let alone wiping with them. And I've noticed that these are the only brand of wipes that actually burn the crap out of my bum when I use them. I'll stick with the Walmart Equate brand because they work great and don't burn.

I’ve purchased this item many times in the past so I’m not sure if it’s a defective batch, but as one wipe is being pulled out of the package, it’s already falling apart. I wasted money on buy a case of this and only to be able to use the immediate middle of the wipes.

I’ve been a big fan for years with your product, but I have recently realized how much you’ve changed the wipes. They are very thin and flimsy now, and aren’t nearly as effective. They often tear just getting them out of the co gained. I will not purchase again. You’ve ruined them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I like the size of the pack of these wet cottonelle wipes. The wipes themselves are not too big or too small, roughly the size of my palm. They smell super fresh. I like that they're also thick and don't break apart. They also weren't too saturated.

duper

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I really love the Cottonelle FreshCare Flushable Wipes. They’re super convenient and easy to carry, I keep a pack in my purse and take it everywhere. The wipes are soft, gentle, and perfect for quick cleanups when I’m out and about. Plus, they’re truly flushable, which makes them even better.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Nice and clean. I'm regularly using it to keep my bathroom surfaces and edges dust and germ free. Its a plus that it is plumber approved and is flushable. No mess. The material is soft and i like the gentle freshness that lingers after it. After use, it can be closed and the lid seals the moisture so they dont dry out.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I got sent this product from influencer for my honest opinion. It’s very effective. I love the scent of it. It’s very biodegradable, but you do have to be careful to not rip it before you actually use the product. The texture of it is great. It doesn’t hurt to use at all and I love the packaging. It’s very useful.

Not good