I was really excited to try this one but it had a sour taste to me, both my son and I agreed. I don't know if it was a bad batch but I don't know that I'd risk trying it again. We enjoyed other flavors though.

Not my favorite. The only comparison I could make was like the candy bar, which I haven't had in a long time though. More cookie tasting maybe? Not sure.

Disappointed in this one. Big cookie and cream fan but after having the cinnamon roll I think I expected too much. Probably wouldn't get this one again.

Absolutely fantastic flavor. I personally love cookies and creamed flavor ice cream, chocolate bars you name it. The consistency is on point and it doesn't taste like chalk. Would recommend as a larger portion of your box.

I didn't like the flavor and the texture. I tried it with 4oz of milk to eat from a bowl and it was not what I was hoping. The pieces are so big. I would shred the oatmeal before soaking.

Really enjoyed how much like a dessert this was. Was a nice healthy way to deal with my sweet tooth without too much sugar. Plus it kept me full from lunch till dinner.

It did not taste natural. It tasted like a gross protein bar with alcohol sweetener, but worse because of the texture. I kind of gagged it down. I prefer other flavors better. Maybe it will grow on me.

This was the first flavor that I tried. I liked it. I have had protein shakes and overnight oats, but this texture is like soggy cereal. It had a good taste, and I look forward to trying the different flavors.

Really good! Definitely evoked the cookies and cream vibe. I do wish there were more little cookie pieces, the texture would have been really enjoyable! Still a solid 9/10.

I'm not sure why they claim is this everyone's favorite. This is my least favorite so far. Chocolate chips get stuck in your teeth and mouth was left chalky.