I'd really like to give this a 4.5 or something closer to a 5... I love anything cookies and cream, especially with peanut butter (hint hint).. and this is delicious going down, but this one seemed to leave a bit of an unpleasant after tatse.

I had my doubts that there would be an aftertaste. You usually have to get used to a different taste if it's healthy. Well I was proven wrong. This is delicious. I used almond milk. I will definitely reorder !!

I used 8 oz unsweetened vanilla almond milk, overnight (about 10-12 hour soak). It's not bad, but it's not good. It didn't seem to have much flavor. I won't be reordering this one.

Bought a verity pack to try for lunch at work( I travel the entire United States for work) and this was an easy on the go small meal . Love it! Will be buying more

It did not taste natural. It tasted like a gross protein bar with alcohol sweetener, but worse because of the texture. I kind of gagged it down. I prefer other flavors better. Maybe it will grow on me.

Doesn't taste anything like cookies and cream. Just tastes like artificial/chemical flavoring, like a bad protein shake. I had to force myself to finish it. Yuck! There are definitely better flavors than this one.

I only ordered one, not expecting to totally love it. It was really good. All your flavors are strong, but it didn't make me feel yucky, like I was eating a bunch of oreos. I'm reordering 2 this time.

It's ok. As I've said with all flavors I've tried so far, it's delicious if you're used to healthier, lower sugar foods, but if you have a lifetime of eating whatever you want with no concern for health factors, it can be a little blah.

Made with whole milk (cow) and refrigerated for 6 hours, it was great in texture and consistency. The flavor wasn't a match for ice cream, but it was a good one for a cookies & cream type. Good GF cookie pieces. Will eat again.

So easy with good amount of protein and fiber. Really tasty, but it's actually a little sweeter than I'd prefer. You can notice the protein powder, but the flavor isn't overwhelming. Excited to try more!