I never thought my teenager would eat oatmeal. He saw my first box and said he'd give the cookies and cream a try. He's obsessed! I placed an order the NEXT day for more - he thinks it tastes great, keeps him full and is perfect for his busy schedule with hockey practice and daily workouts.

Surprisingly I didn't like this one. I think the ratio of milk for it is off and I'd at a minimum use half as much milk as recommended. The texture wasn't as smooth as some of the other flavors and it didn't really have one stand out flavor to it so as I was eating it I didn't feel like I was really getting any flavor to enjoy. So between the texture and lack of flavor I wouldn't recommend.

Nope! Nah! Hard pass! Gritty! Separated overnight and in between shaking it. Was just off. Couldn't tell the flavor either - had to double check what the package said. Don't know if this was an earlier version? The grittiness was like whey protein powders you can find that don't dissolve/mix/blend well.

Absolutely my favorite. Not a big cookies and cream person, but also not a big oatmeal person. But the 2 together pair so good. The product truly is pretty darn good. But hard to get over the slimy texture. For me it taste great but it's a texture thing. If you like oatmeal, you'll love it

OMG! I've never been a fan of oats / oatmeal as I'm very finnicky with textures but I decided to give this a try and I loved it! Tasted just like a milkshake but not too sweet for a breakfast item. Honestly, my everyday breakfast now for on-the-go. Thank you for changing my views on oats. Delicious!

I really enjoy the product but it's just too expensive to buy regularly when I can make the same thing for pennies. There's also far too much packaging involved for the environmentally conscious. Use of products like those from FootprintUS.com could help you with people of that demographic like myself.

I read on the package this is the owners favorite flavor and I'm gonna have to agree. This is my favorite one so far!! It's so good!! I use oat milk. I put it in the freezer for like 20 mins and then poof the oats in. Anyone who I have had try these has loved them too!!! I highly recommend this flavor!! When I order more I will get multiples of this one

This flavor is my favorite. I will definitely be ordering more of it in the next box. If you love cookies & cream milkshakes, you'll love this! Sometimes I don't like this flavor because it's too chocolatey, but this recipe nailed the title it is cookies AND cream.

This is the flavor I kept seeing promoted on Instagram videos that made me want to try Oats Overnight. But the flavor was so mild that it didn't feel like I was drinking cookies and cream flavored oats. Just felt like I was drinking a slightly sweet oat drink. It wasn't bad, but just wish the flavor was stronger.

This flavor is clearly popular with others but to me it tastes exactly like cookies and cream protein powder, including the aftertaste. It's not awful but definitely not something I'd look forward to eating and doesn't taste like an actual Oreo or cookies and cream milkshake.