Cookies and Cream was good but not a "go to" for me. I'm not sure I'll be putting more of it in my OO boxes in the future. It had a decent flavor, but I really didn't get the "cookies and cream" taste that was suggested. Where is the cookie? The name suggests the iconic Oreo cookie, yet there is no trace of it to be found. The flavor isn't bad, just underwhelming. I gave it a '7'.

It reminds me of my husbands favorite ice cream. Bold flavor that tastes like a shake. It has the right balance of cookies and the creamy texture. The chia seeds are a nice touch with the oats. I finished it before the oats had a chance to soak up the milk. Delicious!

This is the flavor I kept seeing promoted on Instagram videos that made me want to try Oats Overnight. But the flavor was so mild that it didn't feel like I was drinking cookies and cream flavored oats. Just felt like I was drinking a slightly sweet oat drink. It wasn't bad, but just wish the flavor was stronger.

The consistency is very offputting when made with a full 8 ounces of milk. I gagged every time I tried to drink it. I think next time I will use less milk and see if I could just eat it without issue (as the alternative prep). The flavor itself was OK. It wasn't oh my goodness wow but it wasn't terrible.

Absolutely my favorite. Not a big cookies and cream person, but also not a big oatmeal person. But the 2 together pair so good. The product truly is pretty darn good. But hard to get over the slimy texture. For me it taste great but it's a texture thing. If you like oatmeal, you'll love it

So I've been having my overnight oats for almost a week now and omg the cookies and crème one taste so good!! I don't think I've even enjoyed oatmeal until I got these!! I could literally enjoy it everyday and my boyfriend has tried same and likes it too!!

This is the first one I tried and I definitely want to try it again. I wasn't sure about the overnight oats when I first tasted the consistency but now I LOVE IT!! I will definitely be trying this one again in my next batch bc I will probably love it

The flavor of this product was classic cookies and cream without an oatmeal feel at all, even though I mixed to the spoon level rather than the drink level. The one downside is that I have had bariatric surgery and need smaller portion sizes. I can eat only half at a time. The second half is not as good after sitting the remainder of the day in the refrigerator.

Tastes like dessert for breakfast and it's healthy for you! I am so impressed by the taste, and I look forward to trying more flavors. This is a good flavor choice if you are craving something sweet. I'd choose this over the sugary breakfasts any day of the week!

Liked it better than the cookie dough but could use some zhuzhing up. Sweet and tasty but not super cookie and cream vibe to me...just enough to make me feel it's worth buying again to give it a second try as a thicker overnight oat (made in Shaker as drink)