I didn't notice a prominent flavor of anything with this one. It didn't taste bad, but it didn't taste like Cookies & Cream to me.

This is a fan favorite but for me, it did not excite. I did not dislike it but I won't be adding it to my subscription box much.

I'll admit that I didn't read the instructions and made the mixture in the reverse order. So, I'm not sure I used the correct amount of Milk. However, I did like the flavor even though I'd never had cookies and creme flavored oatmeal before. Once I've had the chance to try more and correctly make the meal, I'll leave another review.

Literally the best. My favorite flavor candy bar growing up was the cookies and cream, and I loved C&C ice cream if ANY kind- I'd make my own! If Oreo hasn't endorsed you for natural Oreo - they have to! Honestly, this is such a refreshing take on it! You can tell it's real. Love it. I know it says you're not supposed to use dairy substitute...but I absolutely love it with OAT milk 🫣 please don't come after me, O-Oat gods!!

10/10 There were a lot of rave reviews about this one and I didn't buy into it. I figured it'd end up tasting like any Cookies and Cream protein shake... I was wrong! It was pretty spot on with the flavor it was aiming for and the texture of everything was perfect. No wonder it's the Founders Favorite! (21Aug)

My partner took it to work and said that it was amazing. He's a breakfast hater which is one of the reasons why I wanted to try it. He took it to work said it was amazing, he let his coworker try a bite and the coworker loved it. My partner said “I wasn't expecting it to be that awesome, but I can't wait to try a new flavor tomorrow”

This was the first flavor I tried, and while it wasn't bad, I just did not love it. It wasn't sweet enough, and didn't really taste like cookies and cream. I did enjoy how filling it was without making me feel too full, especially early in the morning.

This was the first flavor I tried, and I have no regrets! I used oatmilk, I filled it a tad over the “drink me” line and had to add a bit more the next day. It was similar to a cookies and cream milkshakes, very enjoyable. It'll continue to be in every box I order!

I liked this a lot. My husband said it just tasted like chocolate, which he was not completely wrong. The chocolate is very forward, and towards the end it is about all you notice, but not in a bad way. It really did remind me of cookies and cream milkshake in flavor.

This was the first one I tried. I've never had overnight oats before this. I did the exact measurements, and though it was delicious, it was a bit too sweet. (I modified for the other ones by adding extra milk, which made it perfect). Aside from that, love the taste, and love the texture (because I am able to crush the chia seeds and some other seeds). It also filled me up.