I ordered the most of these based on other reviews. Maybe I was expecting too much, but I did not enjoy this flavor. It didn't taste like much and the cookies made it a grey color that was not appetizing. I really enjoy the fruit flavors, so maybe I'm just not the target audience for this one!

A little too much like dessert. I'm really not sure why I ordered it. It's just that it was my first order and I wanted to try everything and it looked like something that might be good, but in general, I'm not big on cookies and cakes and pies and candy especially not for breakfast.

Cookies & cream is my favorite flavor in ice cream, chocolate, and cookies! I had high hopes for this and very high expectations! Honestly tastes so amazing! You can taste the whey protein which I don't mind but I personally love that I can easily have this to get rid of that sweet tooth!

This flavor is clearly popular with others but to me it tastes exactly like cookies and cream protein powder, including the aftertaste. It's not awful but definitely not something I'd look forward to eating and doesn't taste like an actual Oreo or cookies and cream milkshake.

This was a nice way to get my Oreo fix. I wish it had a bit more cookies and cream, however probably a good thing it doesnt so I dont crave the Oreos more. I like the nutritional values and content within this one, and it helps me with my healthy lifestyle plan.

I'll admit that I didn't read the instructions and made the mixture in the reverse order. So, I'm not sure I used the correct amount of Milk. However, I did like the flavor even though I'd never had cookies and creme flavored oatmeal before. Once I've had the chance to try more and correctly make the meal, I'll leave another review.

This was the first flavor I tried, and I have no regrets! I used oatmilk, I filled it a tad over the “drink me” line and had to add a bit more the next day. It was similar to a cookies and cream milkshakes, very enjoyable. It'll continue to be in every box I order!

I didn't like this flavor as much as I thought I would. It's not bad, but maybe a little bland, and not as creamy as I had hoped either. I enjoyed it, but for me there are better flavors out there. I probably won't order this again any time soon, though I'll give it another chance down the road.

Super easy and great taste! As a new mom breastfeeding it's hard to get in good calories and protein quick and these are the perfect solution where I don't even have to think about it. Just put in the fridge the night before and am set for the morning.

This flavor is pure comfort in a cup. Oats Overnight absolutely nailed the Cookies & Cream—it's creamy, chocolatey, and has that nostalgic cookie flavor without being overly sweet. It honestly feels like I'm having a milkshake for breakfast, but without the guilt. The texture is smooth and satisfying after soaking overnight, and the little cookie-like bits give it just the right amount of crunch and flavor contrast. It's indulgent, but still packed with protein and keeps me full all morning. If you're someone who likes dessert-for-breakfast vibes but still wants something balanced and energizing, this one's a must. Definitely one of my top favorites from their lineup!