I've had a few different ones as well and they just weren't for me or my wife.

This is just me. I'm not a big chocolate fan, and this had a bit much chocolate for me.

This delivered the perfect flavor! Loved it cold on a hot day.

It was pretty mild . Could have done with more " cookie flavor"

This flavor was okay but there are flavors much better.

It definitely wasn't what I was hoping it would be. Would not order this flavor again.

The texture was a little different but the flavor was great!

Good taste. I made it both ways - drinking or with a spoon. Either was good.

I love it. It's not overly sweet but can bearly notice that cookies are supposed to be in it

Also very yummy! One of my favorite flavors of ice cream.