Hey Beth, We're really sorry to hear that you did not enjoy the Cookies & Cream with Oat Milk. We'd love to recommend some prep methods that may be a better fit for you. If you're finding that the flavors need a little more sweetness, dairy milk is a great solution if that's an option for you. If they're a bit too sweet, we recommend using unsweetened almond milk. We have several flavors to choose from and we would be happy to send you replacements for new flavors of your choice for the packets you've used already or the flavors you haven't enjoyed with your next order. Reach out to us at support@oatsovernight.com and we'll help you in every way we can! Best, Koree Oats Overnight