Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Old Spice Swagger Deodorant, Aluminum-Free, 3 oz., 4 pk. for
Old Spice Swagger Deodorant, Aluminum-Free, 3 oz., 4 pk.
4.4 out of 5 stars
stars
434 ratings434 reviews
  1. 5 stars69% (299)
  2. 4 stars18% (79)
  3. 3 stars3% (14)
  4. 2 stars1% (5)
  5. 1 star9% (37)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 31-40 of 434 reviews
Mar 8, 2025
Dontbuy2025
1 out of 5 stars review

Waste of money!

I bought six of these a few days ago, the smell good for anything is a complete joke. I work in an office environment, shower every day, and the most this product will last is four hours if you're lucky. Something seems to have changed in the formula. Do not waste your money on this as I assure you, it does not work. Will never buy this product again.

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Oct 12, 2019
Freez
1 out of 5 stars review

Used this for many years.. not any more

I have used this deodorant for over 10 years and it was consistently great. After a recent purchase, that smelled awful, I thought maybe I got a "bad batch", so I purchased it 2 more times and it smells terrible now. Seems like this happened when they added the "aluminum free" label, maybe they changed the formula. I can no longer use this, as it smells absolutely horrendous. I used to get asked what cologne I was wearing, and it was this deodorant, but now, sadly, I'm in search of a replacement..

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Jan 17, 2020
DLeB
1 out of 5 stars review

New Formula Stinks Literally

I have been buying Old Spice Deodorants since I was a teenager. Sworn by the product. When original formula Swagger came out it was awesome. I noticed the change a while back and I have to say it stinks. How can a company take a formula which is pleasing and pleasant and turn it into one which smells bad? I don't know and now it's no more Swagger for me. I'm 58 years old so however long Swagger has been around I've bought it every few weeks. No more. Customer lost.

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Apr 11, 2012
Bulldog
5 out of 5 stars review

Still nothing better.

I love this product, and always keep a small stock of it out of greed. I've been drenched in sweat, and all out filthy at work. With all that, I still have women tell me how good I smell, and ask what I'm wearing. They think I must wear an awesome cologne, but the truth is they are smelling my OLD SPICE AQUA REEF. This product not only smells great, but never leaves any funky white goo behind either. However, they have cut the amount of product by .25 oz and still charge the same price per unit. YES that bothers me, but not enough to drive me away from the best deodorant ever made. I've been wearing this product for at least six years.

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Jan 26, 2020
Raju
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed on new smell

I cannot belive the change they did on the smell of the original deodorant, I have been buying the original swagger deodorant for 20 years, I even got my brothers in another country to used it because of the pleasant smell it used to have. Please go back to the original smell.

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Feb 24, 2026
PrachyPeach
5 out of 5 stars review

Works and smells great!

Okay so this review is straight from my husband. He tried Old Spice Sweat Defense in Swagger and says one swipe keeps him dry all day. No chalky mess, no surprise dampness. Smells bold but not overpowering. Bonus, matching body wash. He loves it and I love how great he smells.

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Jan 4, 2020
JBH45
1 out of 5 stars review

New Swagger Formula is God Awful

I've been using Swagger since it came out. Not sure when that was. I was pretty stocked up so I haven't purchased any in several months. Just recently ran out and had to buy some, and noticed there was a new label. Cool. I used it for the first time the next morning, and it's terrible. Inexplicably bad. It smells NOTHING LIKE THE ORIGINAL SWAGGER. The two sticks I bought are going in the trash as soon as I find something else I like.

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Jul 25, 2010
Dan
5 out of 5 stars review

Absolutely the Best

PLEASE don't ever stop making Aqua Reef Red Zone. I receive numerous compliments from guys and gals. In addition to that I love the scent and the protection. It last all day and night. Many people ask what cologne am I wearing. I love to tell them that it is just my deodorant! Thank You so much and again PLEASE don't stop making this!

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Jun 30, 2014
John06
5 out of 5 stars review

Awesome deodorant!

I am so glad I tried this product. The Old Spice antiperspirant that I was using was starting to become ineffective at odor control (I've read you can become immune to deodorant, perhaps that was the case) and was causing me to itch. I tried a couple of (well actually every) other brands and had problems ranging from itching to clumped and matted armpit hair to BO in the middle of the day. I've wanted to stop using antiperspirant for a while as the idea of clogging pores seems unhealthy. So, I also tried some natural deodorants, and quite frankly my armpits smell better sans-deodorant than they did with every natural brand I tried. I say all this to say how great this particular product is. I've not had any itching problems, it doesn't make my pit hair clump, and the scent is awesome (it's nice and clean smelling). It is different feeling wetness when I sweat intensely (for instance during a workout), but that is the difference in an antiperspirant and a deodorant. It also controls odor well. As some other deodorant only brands I have tried only masked/mixed with the BO I was a little self conscious at first, and did frequent sniff tests. All day long, even after sweating, I can only smell the deodorant scent when doing a quick sniff under the arm. I have woken up a couple of times and detected a hint of BO that wasn't there when I went to bed, but it wasn't noticeable unless you did a "sniff-check," and I take a shower in the morning anyway, so I don't deem that a problem or weakness of the product. Bottom line, I would absolutely recommend this product!

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394
Feb 4, 2025
Kris1984
3 out of 5 stars review

Blue1

I have been using this product for many years , I think it smells great and last long. Only problem I have is that they use dyes for coloring blue 1 or green 6 ,which I do not find reason to use them. I do. Ot care if is colorless just. Because if the coloring dyes I switched to another brand. I wish you create same product without dyes!

Review from oldspice.com
Helpful?31XL0CETY6N820114818394