I'm going to give them 5 stars for now. My 14 month old is currently a size 4 so I bought a size 5. They're good for him now but will be getting a size 6. They are a little snug so definitely size up, especially if your kids wear thick socks for the cold weather. Unsure if they are waterproof or water resistant.

Size up if you are between sizes. My son is usually a 7 for shoes. Got the 8 and they have enough room but were a lil snug to slide on. But he loves them so far. Thinner material so wears more like a taller shoe, like a walking/hiking boot. Not like a pair of cowboy boots that are stiff and require break in. Just have a ‘western look' Time will tell, but for the price are nice.