These cookies are dangerously delicious! Easy to sit and eat the entire packet in one sitting. Give your soil a little kiss on the cheek with these delectable little treats!

These cookies are so good. I plan to buy more.

These were good tasting, but were like bite-size cookies. I agree they're different than the larger ones in the past but still good.

Mint cookies not as good as lat year- they used to be thicker and larger square ones- we loved them- but now they are like the thin mints girl scouts sell and they are not as good. I had originally planned to buy a few boxes for the neighbors- but not anymore. Very disappointing.

We used to love these. The way they used to make these was much better. It used to be a square shape and had more of the fuge coating on each cookie. Now they are smaller and circular with less cookie and chocolate coated frosting. The quality seems to have gone way down, but the price has not.

Total disappointment! I've previously purchased these for gifts and our own enjoyment. This year, Harry and David changed them from a thicker square cookie to thin little round cookies. Even the taste has gone downhill. Sad that they had to change something that was so good!

No, no,no. Say it's not true. These cookies are now pretty awful. I got a call from my daughter reminding me to pick up the amazing Harry and David Fudge Mint Cookies for the holidays. They have changed so much that they are unrecognizable. They taste like cheap, waxy thin mints with an odd aftertaste. I. Am. So. Sad.

These cookies have been destroyed from the ground up. The original shape, the original size, the original recipe-- all gone in favor of something that resembles girl scout cookies. The flavor? Not even close to what it was. Reduction in mint with additional sugar instead just wrecked these things vWhile they don't suck completely, they were bad enough that I returned all five boxes. What a crime that somebody felt the need to wreck a Christmas classic.

Very disappointed, not what there were like in the past

these are not the same as they were. they used to be large and square and taste good. now they're round, tiny and do not taste the same at all. I am not happy with this purchase, not happy with this product changing, I will not buy again. it's a shame because I've always looked forward to these.