Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Gap Women's Button-Up Cardigan for
Gap Women's Button-Up Cardigan
4.9 out of 5 stars
stars
15 ratings15 reviews
  1. 5 stars93% (14)
  2. 4 stars7% (1)
  3. 3 stars0% (0)
  4. 2 stars0% (0)
  5. 1 star0% (0)

Member photos

  • +27 images
Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 15 reviews
Jun 24, 2026
FabienneC
5 out of 5 stars review

A soft stretchy dark brown long sleeved button down cardigan that can be worn all year long.

I absolutely love this cardigan! The rich dark brown color is timeless and goes with almost everything in my closet. The knit fabric feels soft and cozy without being too heavy or hot. It can be used throughout the year and perfect for layering. The relaxed fit gives it a comfortable, effortless look while still feeling stylish. It can be paired up with jeans for a casual day out or dressed up with accessories for a chic outfit at night. It's comfortable , versatile, and easy to style. The sleeves can be worn as is or can be folded up. The long sleeves provide great coverage and warmth. I love that it's a button down cardigan that can be styled in many different ways. The cardigan is easy to maintain. It can be washed at home with cold water on a gentle cycle. Can be air dried on a hanger or put in the drier on gentle setting.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re absolutely thrilled to hear that you love this cardigan, Fabienne! Thanks so much for the detailed insights on its fabric, fit, and styling versatility. We hope you enjoy it!

Jun 25, 2026
AshleyC
5 out of 5 stars review

Casual or business

This cardigan hits the perfect sweet spot for casual comfort, and a perfect polish appearance. The material is incredibly soft on the skin and perfect to wear your round. It's a reliable wardrobe, staple that can be worn over a graphic tee or business casual top.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re so glad to see that you like this cardigan and found it to be soft, comfortable, and versatile, Ashley! Thank you so much for sharing your valuable insights with us.

Jul 1, 2026
KimC
5 out of 5 stars review

Warm but not hot!

Love the burgundy color and density of the weave yet there is still a cool feeling to the sweater. I generally like my sweaters larger so I ordered an extra- large but probably would have done fine with a large as well because it did not shrink with washing and drying and still looks brand new. My new favorite sweater.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re so happy to hear that this cardigan has become your new favorite sweater, Kim!

May 23, 2026
MF25
5 out of 5 stars review

Cardigan is VERY COMFORTABLE & FIT is AWESOME!

I LOVE this Black Cardgian. I usually wear a 10-12 so ordered an XL . It fits PERFECT! My person size is 5'6" 150 pounds & it's not too tight but, the fit is Soo comfortable!! Black is a Great color to access with many outfits for me, white or a pretty blue top underneath, jean pants (long or short), or black velour pants, etc. The weave is not heavy or too light & fits on my body snuggly. I'll be VERY HAPPY in wearing this Cardigan!! :>)

  • +1 image
Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re thrilled to hear that you love this cardigan and found it to be the perfect fit, MF!

Jun 12, 2026
KathleenS
5 out of 5 stars review

Great fitting sweater

This 100% cotton sweater is both comfortable and practical with the attic convenience of being a machine washable. The fit is excellent and true the size. it can be worn on its own or layered over a shirt/dress. Cropped length fits nicely at the waist creating a flattering lock.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re so pleased to hear that you’re happy with the fit of this cardigan, Kathleen! We love that it can be worn layered or on its own too. Thanks so much for the great review!

Jun 16, 2026
TerryP
5 out of 5 stars review

Beautiful, soft, luxurious cardigan!

I really like this Gap Crew Neck Cardigan! The brown color is great for all seasons. It is incredibly comfortable, soft and lightweight enough to wear all day without feeling bulky. I can easily dress it up for church or throw it on with jeans for a casual look. The quality feels great and has somewhat of a straight, boxy fit. I would definitely recommend this cardigan to anyone looking for a cozy, versatile cardigan sweater.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re thrilled to hear that you like this cardigan and found it to be luxurious and comfortable, Terry. Thanks so much for the great rating, review, and recommendation!

May 28, 2026
JenV
5 out of 5 stars review

Nice cardigan

This cardigan seems very well made. The construction is a heavier sweater material. The color is true to the photo. This would be nice for layering on a cool day and seems like it would hold up well to washing. Classic cardigan look that will be a good staple for your wardrobe.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re so glad to see that you like this cardigan and found it to be well-made, Jen!

May 28, 2026
MichelleB
5 out of 5 stars review

Great heavier weight well made cardigan

Overall fit is a little generous - I'm usually a medium in long sleeve tops and this fit well, though I probably could also wear a small. It will work great as an outer layer / over other shirts, but also looks chic buttoned up. I love the cotton weave -it is super soft and a great weight for cooler weather . The length is perfect , just a tad shorter than other cardigans I have and on trend. Definitely recommend a a wardrobe staple.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re so pleased to see that you like this cardigan and found it soft and well-made, Michelle! Thank you so much for the five-star rating and high recommendation.

May 18, 2026
BKH0
5 out of 5 stars review

I dream of cardigans like this, and you will too

I love cardigans but I'm usually disappointed. Until now. This cardigan is beautiful, it has the perfect weight and I noticed it right out of the package. I checked because I thought there had to be two of them because it was so bulky. After noticing the weight of the cardigan, I unbuttoned the large buttons that were securely fastened and was shocked how well made the cardigan is. I started dreaming of how I will style this: with jeans and a plain white tee or tank top would be the perfect casual throw back to those of us still fondly remembering Rachel and Monica from Friends and their style. This screams of fall, cozy and just amazing. I could keep this in the office for when I need to layer up during those in between seasons months. I could add this with a colorful maxi dress for church. A quality cardigan can have nine lives and this will become your favorite too. Just like it is now mine.

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533
reply from Customer Support Team

We’re absolutely thrilled to hear that this is the cardigan of your dreams, BKH! We definitely agree that it’s the perfect layering piece. Thanks so much for sharing all your thoughts on its quality and wearability. We hope you get a lot of wear out of it this fall!

Jul 5, 2026
DianneE
4 out of 5 stars review

True to size

This cardigan from Gap hits all the right boxes! The color is rich, the fit is good and the it is super cozy. This color is so versatile and I will get a lot of use out of it during the colder months. I would recommend purchasing it!!

Incentivized Review
Helpful?2QTOV8336OCZ19685814533