The ice cream wasn't as firm as I expected, but, that is fine. However, the peanut flavor is prominent with little to no chocolate or sweet flavor. The tiny Reese's pieces on top have absolutely no flavor and no crunch to their outer candy shell. Pretty much there for color. I wish it had more chocolate swirls in it. Nice for a quick cool treat but not as appetizing as I had hoped. I would rather stick a pack of Reese's peanut butter cups in the freezer.

Good portions and very tasty. The reese's pieces aren't crunchy but they are still good

Very good love Reese's once in a while

Disappointed. The “ice cream” is more like a mousse - and definitely nothing like the photo. The size would have been perfect if it had lived up to expectations.

I was extremely dissatisfied. I am a peanut butter freak and didn't even think twice when I saw these in Sam's. We tried them for dessert and wished I hadn't spent the money. Not much peanut butter flavor. If you don't try you won't know.

Was tasty

Awful

I'd buy again

Disappointing

Okay, at best. Not very exciting, and there are NOWHERE near the amount of Reese's Pieces on top as advertised on the box. You can hardly call it a sundae.