would buy these anytime of the year. Please restock!!

These are delicious %26 very fresh tasting. After the first bite, they almost melt in your mouth. I'll be ordering more to share as gifts.

Was a little dry and needed more butter for that melt in your mouth taste. These are sweet, dry, and nothing else. Was disappointed .

The most insipid shortbread I've ever had! Will never buy again. Completely flavorless. DO NOT waste your money on this garbage!

I look forward to these cookies every Christmas season. These are great as gifts. They are even better eaten! The best shortbread cookies!

I have bought these canister cookies for years. But for the past 4 years they seem to taste bland and blah. Last year I ate 2 cookies and threw them all out. I gave it a 2 star rating because I use the cans for storage.

I usually buy these every year, mostly to give as gifts to family, friends, coworkers (and of course, to snack on!). These are some of the best store-bought cookies I have ever had! No one I have ever given them to have ever complained about them or not wanted them. Didn't purchase or give any this year, and I almost had to run for my life at work!!! LOL. And freshness is awesome... Opened the last pack from last year less than a month ago. Still yummy!

These cookies tasted off, cheap taste like fake or inferior butter, and were like consuming desert sand. I tried a few and realized I couldn't give these to family, would almost be embarrassing to give these how bad they tasted in my opinion. First time i've tried a MM product I didn't like. Sam's took care of the issue for me, but I cannot recommend these cookies.

Been getting these for a few years and one or all of this has happened. 1 different manufacturer 2 different recipe 3 definitely not as good as previous years. It seems as though they aren’t as buttery/vanilla flavor, it seems almost like the cheap flower Little Debbie uses in there products. They are eatable but not the OMG eat the whole tin good like previous years. This batch is made in Germany and I believe previous years were made in another country.

I have been buying these cookies to give out during Christmas time for the past 6 years. I am so disappointed this year. I feel like eating sands without any flavors whatsoever. Moreover, the size of these cookies is so much smaller. This will be my last year buying them. Now I don't know what to do with the 43 tins of cookies... I am embarrassed to give them out to my customers.