Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Shortbread Cookies Tin, 4 pk. for
Member's Mark Shortbread Cookies Tin, 4 pk.
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars2,102 ratings581 reviews
  1. 5 stars81% (1,712)
  2. 4 stars7% (143)
  3. 3 stars4% (86)
  4. 2 stars3% (63)
  5. 1 star5% (98)

Member photos

  • +13 images
Sort by |
Showing 131-140 of 581 reviews
Jan 19, 2025
D D Wilson
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Shortbread Cookies

The cookies tasted like they may have been previously frozen. The flavor would have been OK if not for that as they tasted somewhat old. They were well packaged so I don’t believe that was a factor.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Dec 31, 2023
Crystal F
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great office gift idea

I give individual canisters to my boss and workmates every year for the holidays. I get requests to keep on giving them every year. The cookies are yummy!

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Jan 23, 2025
RCarol
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Wish they were available all year long

These are such good cookies. I wish they were available all year long. I don’t really care about the can although it does keep the cookies in good shape.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Jan 4, 2025
S Finley
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Simple but Excellent

These cookies are perfect after all the heavy holiday desserts. They are a light crispy shortbread. I enjoy them with coffee or tea. Great to have on hand to serve company.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Jan 7, 2026
Walter
1 out of 5 stars review

These cookies are called "Shortbread." Upon checking the ingredients I find palm oil listed as the primary fat. True shortbread derives its lucious flavor from butter and when no butter is used in the recipe, these cookies will always come up short (no pun intended) Instead of a nice snack, all the cans went into the trash. What a waste Members Mark. Please source a better product.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Dec 5, 2025
Delic8rose
1 out of 5 stars review

Do Not Buy These Awful Cookies

What a disappointment. I was going to give these as a gift. Glad I tasted them first. It would have been an embarrassment to give these. They just don't taste good. No butter or almond flavor. Sort of a stale, bland flavor. Do not buy these unless you just want the canisters.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Jan 7, 2026
Jan
2 out of 5 stars review

Greasy Tasting

The cookies are crisp/crunchy. The taste is lackluster at best, in fact they have a greasy aftertaste. During an internet search about greasy tasting shortbread cookies, they all reference an incorrect balance of flour to butter in the recipe. Looking at the ingredients there is no butter at all, but there is PALM OIL. The product description mentions a traditional European recipe, not certain how many palms would be found in Europe to source oil from.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Dec 10, 2025
LYNN
2 out of 5 stars review

Cookies are great. I buy them every year. Received order today and the tins were crushed. I bought them to give as gifts and they are useless. I actually buy them frequently when they are available during the holidays but sadly, I will not order to ship ever again. I live 100 miles from every location so I guess I'll find another option for gifts to the mailman, ups and fed ex, etc.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Dec 19, 2025
JASON
3 out of 5 stars review

Labeled as a four pack on the bottom of each tin.

I bought it intending to gift the four tins to four different people. Seemed like a cute idea in the store. But when I got home and unwrapped the package, on the bottom of each tin it says "4 pack shortbread cookies." It just felt cheap, because clearly the receiver knows they're getting a forth of something. Might be fine for a certain "level" of gift- like someone you don't really need much more than a card for, but I had intended to give them to coaches who work pretty hard for us all year. I decided to get something else for them instead because I was uncomfortable giving these.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707
Sep 25, 2024
lauter33
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Ugly mangled tins

Mangled cans were so disappointing. You can buy shortbread cookies anywhere but I wanted the tins that came so crushed they are unusable. I hate this! I'm not driving 21 miles to exchange it so I just threw them away and sucked up the financial loss.

Helpful?2XQXD2HZHBBM19396800707