I have mixed feelings about this one because there is a lot to like, but one major ingredient holds it back for me. On the positive side, the 30g of protein per serving is a massive benefit and makes it a powerhouse for recovery. The consistency is also excellent; it's smooth, easy to drink, and feels high-quality. Even the packaging is nice and well-thought-out. The initial strawberry flavor is actually quite good, but unfortunately, I am just not a fan of stevia. While the first sip is pleasant, the aftertaste lingers in a way that I personally find off-putting. If you are someone who is perfectly fine with stevia, you will likely think the flavor is top-tier. However, because that sweetener choice is a dealbreaker for my palate, I'm giving it 3 stars. Great for the protein goals, but the lingering taste just isn't for me.

I was pleasantly surprised at how much I liked this drink. There was very little artificial aftertaste with this, and I love that it is not fake pink. The color of the strawberry drink is white and I liked it enough to get a case to incorporate this into my daily routine. My two adult daughters tried this as well and both were impressed with the taste. It is gluten free and lactose free, so one of my daughters took one to share with a coworker who has allergies to gluten. The price is great as well.

My overall opinion of the Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk Shake is that it could use some improvement. The flavor I received was Strawberry. I believe it could have a stronger strawberry flavor. It was quite mild and tasted like an off-brand strawberry ice cream. I enjoyed that it had a smooth flavor but the sweetness was too artificial. I loved the 30 grams of protein which is why I wanted it taste better. If the flavor was improved, I think it could be a real contender against other protein drinks.

I've tried many protein shakes, and I can say with certainty that this one is excellent! It has a pleasant aroma and a strawberry flavor that isn't cloying—the sweetness is absolutely perfect. It's great to drink on its own or even to pair with a meal. It makes for a fantastic mid-morning or mid-afternoon snack if you don't want to eat something heavy! I recommend it 100%.

These shakes are my new go to!! The strawberry flavor is delicious!! The shake itself is not pink as there is no artificial colors. This has 30 grams of protein with 160 calories. I use it as a meal replacement or just to help add protein to hit my daily goal. There is no aftertaste with these and that is hard to find. I think this one actually beats the name brand one at a fraction of the price!!

These protein Milkshakes are the best strawberry shakes I have ever tried. They are not overly sweet but do you have enough sweetness to satisfy a sweet craving while providing much needed protein for your day. There is no chalkiness and no aftertaste of artificial sweetener. I am very picky about protein shakes, and only have one or two that I will consume consistently. This one will be added to my rotation for sure.

These milksharkes are very creamy and tastes like strawberries. It is on the sweeter side. It has so much protein to fill you up fast. My teenage son really liked them a lot. My husband thought they were too sweet so it depends on your preference.

It was a little difficult to open, the perforated plastic was hard to grip onto and did not want to tear completely, but once I got it opened I was surprised to see the strawberry milk wasn't colored pink like most other strawberry flavored products. The taste is very good and the texture is smooth and just a bit thicker than regular whole milk. After a day of working in the yard, it was a nice refresher and the extra protein was a nice boost to help alleviate some of my muscle soreness. It's good both at room temperature and chilled. The strawberry flavor is noticeable but not overwhelming and very enjoyable. I'm looking forward to trying the vanilla kind next and seeing how it tastes in my coffee.

This protein milkshake was delicious. It was really smooth but i made sure to shake it until it didnt move anymore. Like really shook it. It didnt have any weird aftertaste and was not colored, it looked like regular milk. I didnt mix it with anything else. It was good on its own.

I was pretty pleased with the strawberry flavored milkshake. It tastes almost identical to the strawberry milk I would have when I was a kid The only difference is this has 2 g of sugar and the other one has over 25 This also has 30 g of protein I did think the consistency would've been a little more frothy, but it is the same consistency as whole milk Overall, I thought it tasted good and was filling enough to replace either a small meal or a snack I would definitely buy again.