We got all duplicates and only half the characters in two separate boxes! We now have 4 of each character we received. For $20 that's a rip off and not at all what is advertised. Lame.

Cute but we received 3 duplicates and are missing the 3 my daughter really wanted. Now she has to decide not to use them on our 4th pool day and return them or deal with not having the ones she wanted. We were missing Floyd, Bevin, and Junie.

We bought in store and no packages had duplicates. The kids absolutely love them. Huge hit for all ages. They do have a terrible smell when you first open them. A couple of days of pool time and the smell has gone away

We love squish mallows at our house. So my daughter was so disappointed when she realized she didn't get all the characters pictured on the packaging. They are so cute, but disappointed we didn't get all the different ones listed.

I bought these in store. Six of the divers were repeats, which means I was missing six characters. I wrote to Big Mouth and they sent me the six missing divers at no cost! Thanks for having awesome customer service.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I m really i love with this water squishmallow they are so cute and have a little weight for the water have a really good buoyancy feels so good when you squeeze i really love this.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These squishmallow diving toys set were the best the kids love it and the individual characters were lovely. The kids enjoy playing with the toys.

Duplicates! You can tell by the shape of the plastic cover it's supposed to come with them all but there were duplicates three designs and in my daughters opinion the cutest ones were missing. We returned it.

These are adorable and the grandkids are obsessed with them! I initially hesitated to buy them because of the reviews, however, we had no duplicates. So maybe the manufacturer has paid attention to the concerns. I highly recommend them!

We are missing 2 characters and have duplicates. Kind of disappointing when it says that all 16 are in the box. They were all like this