I was hoping that this product would taste more like a vanilla milkshake than it did… It left a terrible aftertaste…I was also disappointed to discover that it has artificial sweeteners, Which probably accounts for why there is such a terrible aftertaste.

This is hands down the best vanilla protein shake I have ever had. It tastes like a melted vanilla frosty. It’s smooth and has the perfect amount of real vanilla flavor. I usually hate vanilla for protein because it’s typically gross and artificial tasting but these shakes are delicious!

I’m not typically a big fan of protein drinks, especially the creamy kind but I was pleasantly surprised by these. They have a great flavor, are packed with protein and are an amazing price compared to the competitors. I would definitely give it a try.

Finally, a protein shake that actually tastes great! These shakes are smooth and don't have that chalky aftertaste you find with other brands. We love using them as a high-protein coffee creamer/meal replacement in the mornings. It's a huge time-saver for our busy schedules and much more affordable than name-brand alternatives.

I'm not sure I have words to convey how great these shakes are. To me, they taste like snow cream. My son also likes them and says they taste like a milkshake. I was a little hesitant because vanilla is not my “go to” flavor. However, these shakes have nice texture, great flavor, and a nutritional profile similar to other ultra filtered milks. Do yourself a favor and give these a try!

The vanilla flavor is really good. I highly recommend it. The only drawback is how hard it is to open each shake. There is a plastic wrapper on the outside of the lid for safety. I get it. However, once you remove that, there's another foil piece to remove under the lid. Seems like overkill.

These shakes are great, smooth vanilla flavored shakes. They are not chalky or gritty they are a thicker milk consistancy and do not have any after taste. They are refreshing and provide a sense of being full. They are better than the name brand version in my opinion.

The flavor of this protein shake is excellent. It has a nice, smooth vanilla flavor that isn't fake or overpowering. It really does taste just like a milkshake! It is just the the consistency- not too thin, not too thick. It isn't chalky or powdery and goes down smooth. However, I have to give this 3 stars due to the packaging that makes this very difficult to open. The bottle is wrapped in plastic that goes up and around the lid, so you have to peel the plastic off from the lid to be able to screw it off. There is also a metal seal glued down around the opening of the bottle. It is so tight to the bottle that it makes it very difficult to pull it off. I usually buy the Fairlife brand protein drinks and those simply have the screw-on cap; no seal and no plastic up over the top. I really like the flavor of this drink but I am hesitant to purchase more unless the packaging is changed. I understand the seals are for safety and to prevent leakage but I feel there has to be a better way than struggling to get the bottle open every morning. I do recommend this product for flavor - but just keep in mind you'll need that extra protein to get the bottle open!

Member's Mark Vanilla Milkshakes are a great treat that really deliver on both flavor and quality. From the first sip, you get a rich, creamy texture that is rich without being overly heavy. The vanilla flavor is smooth and well balanced, not too sweet, making it enjoyable for both kids and adults.

This member marks brand protein is out of this world! Taste exactly of a vanilla ice cream, what more could you want! Even though the flavor profile is ice cream, there's little to no sugar at 2g. For me however, it was still on the sweeter side than I hope for. Nonetheless 30g of protein for 150 calories, those macros can't be beat!