Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk Shake, Vanilla, 11.5 fl. oz., 12 pk. for
Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk Shake, Vanilla, 11.5 fl. oz., 12 pk.

Customer photos

  • +883 images
Sort by |
Showing 751-760 of 932 reviews
Dec 7, 2025
Patti
1 out of 5 stars review

Not a comparable Dupe for Fairlife

This is not a comparable dupe to the Fairlife protein drinks. Even though the ingredients are almost identical, the flavor is not even close and tastes off. Not sure if we just received a bad batch as there are many positive reviews, but we definitely won't be purchasing again. This item can't be returned so I'll be donating the extra case and unopened bottles to a food pantry.

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Nov 21, 2025
ANGELA
2 out of 5 stars review

MILK OF MAGNESIA 🤮

I wanted so bad to love these but there is a weird flavor that is hard to describe. It kind of tastes like milk of magnesia, but without the chalkiness. It even smells like milk of magnesia. If it weren't for that, they would probably be pretty good.I am hoping at some point Sam's will reformulate that taste. So for now, I have to say that Nuri is definitely better tasting.

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Dec 28, 2025
RICHARD
3 out of 5 stars review

Just so-so

Taste not too bad but not as good as Fairlife Nutrition Plan Chocolate. The Members Mark not only have a shrink wrapped seal around the neck nut also a foil seal on the top on the bottle, both are a pain to remove. Fairlife is mush easier to open also as it is just a twist to break the plastic ring off the lid.

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Dec 1, 2025
ALISON
5 out of 5 stars review

I really like these. They have a very nice vanilla flavor. I keep them in the refrigerator and when I get up in the morning, put one in the freezer for about 30 minutes. This makes them more like a "milk shake". I hope they change the chocolate flavor to this formulation, because they could be improved. If you like vanilla, I think you'd like these (I'm super picky.)

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Nov 21, 2025
BRENDA
5 out of 5 stars review

Delicious!

I was so happy to see a new protein shake available in something other than chocolate! I've always been a fan of vanilla. I was a bit skeptical, at first, because I've tried a few new ones that were AWFUL! But, I am glad to report that this one is DELICIOUS! Members Mark hit the nail on the head for me with this one. I will definitely be buying again!

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Nov 21, 2025
Alice
3 out of 5 stars review

Obviously this is the Members Mark's take on fairlife ultra filtered protein %26 the texture is smooth without any clumps. But the vanilla flavor is...off. A bit more like premier protein than the melted ice cream like flavor of fairlife. Decent for the price but not an unrecognizable dupe. The bottles feel like they use a lot more plastic than necessary

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Nov 21, 2025
Protein4life
5 out of 5 stars review

Creamy Vanilla

This vanilla protein shake is absolutely amazing! It's super creamy with a smooth texture and has a rich, yummy vanilla flavor that doesn't taste chalky like some other shakes. It feels like a treat while still giving me the protein boost I need. Highly recommend!

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Apr 28, 2026
Brian
3 out of 5 stars review

Stinks

Smells like what produces gas after a night of bingingTaco Bell, could you fix that please? it would make these much more enjoyable.

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Apr 28, 2026
anonymous
5 out of 5 stars review

Recommend!

Excellent alternative to discontinued Fairlife Nutrition Plan Vanilla. Excellent French vanilla flavor. Excellent value.

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141
Apr 19, 2026
Shannon
1 out of 5 stars review

It has 4 different artificial sweeteners and tastes very fake. the artificial, chemical taste takes over every aspect of this drink.

Helpful?30E9VGWJ4D8G18025703141