This product is really good the shake itself, however, the packaging totally sucks. First, you have to take the plastic off the outside, then peel off a foil cap underneath the actual cap, and then the edge of the bottle where you drink from is sharp. A real bummer the packaging ruined these for us.

I really like this shake.. but I buy protein shakes for when I am on the go, so usually they are chugged in the car between drop off, pickup, job sites, etc. The process to get it open is maddening compared to other similar protein shakes. This has an exterior seal to tear off, a lid, and an interior seal to peel off. Compare this to others that are just a pop-top can or you just open a well-sealed bottle... when you're driving, you just need to get it open safely and quickly!

I was excited to give this a try in both the strawberry and vanilla varieties. My initial taste with both exceeded my expectations. The flavors to both were really good and rivaled the tastes of the Nurri ultra filtered protein milk shakes. My only issue with the Members Mark varieties was that there were annoying lumps as you nearly finish the bottle, which felt gross when detected. I even attempted to vigorously shake each bottle prior to consumption, but this did not fix the issue, and I have not purchased since.

The flavor of the shakes is delicious…if you can get to it. Removing the wrapper is difficult, removing the lid is difficult, and then you’re met with a foil seal which is, you guessed it, difficult to remove. I am currently recovering from cervical fusion and am in a neck brace so I am having to drink these through a straw. It’s disgusting. No matter how hard it is shaken or how many different directions it is shaken, there are *always* chunks at the bottom. Normally, you wouldn’t notice this. I am assuming that is the protein. So, if it is not mixing well, you may not be getting the full amount of protein—just something to keep in mind. I thought they were great before my surgery…until I had to drink them through a straw.

Not comparable to the Nurri Vanilla Milk Shake protein shakes at all. There’s not a milk shake flavor at all, just plain vanilla. The texture is odd and the after taste is bad. The SMELL is worst part. Shakes expire in 7 months but smell like sour milk.

I literally love these protein shakes. I get them all the time!! The taste is soo good, it literally tastes like melted ice cream. Also it’s a pretty affordable price compared to other protein shakes. I saw they came out with a strawberry version so i’ll definitely be giving that a try. Only thing that might bother people is sometimes there is a little thicker settlement and it can be weird to drink but if you shake it well it shouldn’t be a problem. Definitely give it a try!!

Ok so, I never leave reviews but love this protein shake so much I felt like I had to. This is my new favorite, most vanilla flavors claim to taste like a vanilla milkshake but this one really does. Will keep buying these, I hope they never discontinue them. Love the strawberry flavor too!

Taste is average, which I can deal with. What's awful about these is the random glob at the bottom, providing the visceral response you'd get if you swallowed a hunk of mucus that didn't originally belong to you. Yes I shake them up very well, but about every third bottle has this unwelcome surprise. The other issue I have is the container itself, thick plastic. I'll go back to the MM shakes with no globs and mostly cardboard containers.

I'm only giving it a 3 becasue the flavor is good, however this is the second case where there has been white flakes at the bottom (after shaking well) and one bottle had like a slime of white coming out of it. I also don't like how it's sealed on the outside as well as under the cap. I won't buy this brand again.

I had high hopes for a cheaper alternative to Fairlife since it has became so expensive but this is not it. It smells nasty but i still tried it and the taste was just as bad. I didn't want to waste it but after gritting my teeth and drinking half of it i had to throw it out. What a waste.