Excellent protein shake choice! I've tried a number of protein shake choices, and this one is a big brand dupe. Great flavor, no funky texture, tastes like a milkshake. Even my kids enjoy it. Highly recommend.

These are the grossest shakes I've ever had! It leaves the worst after taste. I didn't even drink them. I opened 2 and tried to drink them but couldn't.

Both times I bought these they had chunks in them. I've shaken them, smacked them on the table and there are always chunks. This morning I had to strain my shake to drink it. Do better, Member's Mark.

Works well if added to recipes for protien smoothies. I do not recommend drinking it straight from the bottle as it tastes very similar to kaopectatec/chalky tasting.

This is great! I think the taste is really good. I have even added my chocolate protein powder in it, still tastes good and brings protein to 60g. The strawberry is good too.

Very hard to open. Had to use a knife to get the lid seal off then there is a foil seal on the opening that is impossible to pull up and off. I will not buy again because of the packaging. Flavor tastes like ice cream and it is good.

Without vanilla fairlife for $30 a pack I could hardly function. Now with this delicious dupe for almost half the price, I've been saved!! The flavor is delicious. The texture is smooth. The protein is high! Love these shakes so much!!

Unfortunately I returned these. It had a weird aftertaste and was not good. I wanted to love these for the price, but I couldn't get past the taste! Disappointed

Definitely not the worst tasting protein drink I’ve ever had, and the texture is good, with no gritty/graininess or slimy feeling you sometimes get with other protein drinks. However, I couldn’t help but notice a very strong plastic-like taste to these drinks, in both flavors offered (vanilla and strawberry). It was really off-putting, and it was even noticeable when I used the vanilla flavor in my morning coffee. I won’t be buying these again for this reason alone. If Sam’s Club fixed this plastic taste, I would happily try them again.

On the fence about this. Good taste and not super heavy feeling. Mixes great with coffee to make a protein packed iced coffee BUT nearly all of my bottles I purchased around 4/26 of this year (4 days ago) have chunks in them.. I had to strain them all out into a big jug because I am huge on textures. Again the taste is fine, I don’t think they are ‘bad’ as in expired but if you have a weak stomach, idk if I would risk it. Expiration date is January 2027 btw