So I have tried virtually ever brand that exist at this point. I tend more toward the vanilla flavored protein shakes. There is only one other brand that compares to Members Mark vanilla and that is the Equate Brand. Since Equate is Walmart and so technically is Sam's Club, you would think they would be the same but they are not. Close but the Equate is a bit better. None the less, if you haven't tried this vanilla, do so because it's simply done right! The flavor, the right texture and no funky after taste! Simply delicious!

I keep finding chunks in these even after shaking vigrously for 30 seconds. The top of the bottle smells like farts and no it's not my own breath. The Nurri or Fairlife shakes are soooo much better. I usually live Member's Mark products but this one isn't for me.

the shake is OK in taste but the clumps of something resembling cottage cheese stay on the bottom no matter how much and how long you shake. I had to run them through the strainer before drinking. I am very sensitive for clumps on stuff in the drink so needless to say it was very difficult to use and will absolutely do not purchase again.

The first initial taste is good but the after taste is bad, idk how to even describe it its such a weird taste. It's also more on the watery side too, i prefer my protein shakes smoother and creamier which is just my preference. And no matter how much you shake it there will always be clumps at the bottom of the bottle. Idk if it was just the case i got but every single bottle had clumps at the bottom.

I was reading reviews to see if anyone else was finding clumps in their shakes. Glad I found 1 that mentioned clumps. Its really sad, even after shaking aggressively, clumps. First time buying g and using these and I bought 2 cases. Returning unopened one. Aside from that product is good.

Amazing when used with the new Starbucks Crema collection premium instant coffee. Instead of using water or milk I use this vanilla flavored protein shake in conjunction with that. Comes out to 220 cal total. I also tried it with the Nescafé gold espresso brand, not as good but still doable, less calories with that. Overall, even by itself, the vanilla protein shake does not leave a weird aftertaste and doesn't have that odd diet flavor.

I was very pleasantly surprised when I tasted a sample at the store. It tastes like a real vanilla milkshake %26 can't beat the 30gm protein and only 150 cal. I've been drinking Nuri and this is so much better!. Nuri tastes like it's watered down compared to this. So glad I purchased some that day; have been drinking %26 mixing it with fruit in my blender ever since.

These shakes taste really good but have two huge problems. One is that despite shaking before opening, a few of the bottles had gross chunks at the bottom. Non starter. The second is that these are incredibly annoying to open. Most protein shakes just have the plastic cap you crack open and that's it. These have an annoying plastic wrap cover, cap, AND foil top underneath . Why. No other shake does all three of these. I'll be going back to the tastier Nurri shakes which have a simple can open top, are aluminum and thus much more recyclable, and don't get random gross chunks.

These taste delicious, if you like vanilla.

High in protein tastes like a Vanilla shake.