Member’s Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk Shake in Vanilla is a solid choice if you want a high-protein drink that actually tastes like real milk. Each bottle packs around 30 grams of protein with low sugar and moderate calories, making it great for quick breakfasts or post-workout recovery. The flavor is a big highlight—smooth, creamy, and similar to melted vanilla ice cream without being overly sweet. Unlike many protein shakes, it isn’t chalky and goes down easy. The only downside is a slight artificial sweetener aftertaste for some people, and it’s not a full meal replacement. Overall, it’s a great-tasting, convenient, and affordable protein shake.

The taste was good, I bought the strawberry. Unfortunately 10 to 15 minutes later I started to feel hot. My face and arms turned red and itchy. I had to take Benadryl, and put on my face cold towels. Something added in the ingredients did not agree with me. It was very scary I will stick to ensures!

The protein drink had a great taste—it honestly reminded me of vanilla ice cream. If you enjoy protein drinks but don’t like how thick most of them are, this is a great option. It has a lighter, more milk-like texture, which makes it really easy to drink and enjoy.

I was reading reviews to see if anyone else was finding clumps in their shakes. Glad I found 1 that mentioned clumps. Its really sad, even after shaking aggressively, clumps. First time buying g and using these and I bought 2 cases. Returning unopened one. Aside from that product is good.

What a disappointment. They're disgusting. The flavor is odd and is as bad as the protein shakes that use protein powder. It also has clumps in it. I don't want my milk product to have chunks in it. Very unnerving feeling to have a chunk go across your lips and into your mouth. Clearly, the thickener they're using isn't being mixed well. I would not recommend; and, I will not be purchasing again.

I've tried other high-protein shakes that just do not taste good. I often need to resort to the lower protein content version just to make it palatable. Not the case with these vanilla-flavored milk shakes. They give you 30g of protein with only 2g sugar and 150 calories. They help me to feel full while providing the extra protein I am looking for. And it tastes great. They are also very smooth - must be the "ultra-filtered" effect. I also like that they have a foil seal in addition to the cap. I feel like it will help keep it fresher.

The first initial taste is good but the after taste is bad, idk how to even describe it its such a weird taste. It's also more on the watery side too, i prefer my protein shakes smoother and creamier which is just my preference. And no matter how much you shake it there will always be clumps at the bottom of the bottle. Idk if it was just the case i got but every single bottle had clumps at the bottom.

So I have tried virtually ever brand that exist at this point. I tend more toward the vanilla flavored protein shakes. There is only one other brand that compares to Members Mark vanilla and that is the Equate Brand. Since Equate is Walmart and so technically is Sam's Club, you would think they would be the same but they are not. Close but the Equate is a bit better. None the less, if you haven't tried this vanilla, do so because it's simply done right! The flavor, the right texture and no funky after taste! Simply delicious!

This shake was right on point an the flavor was good with no after taste. I really enjoyed alone and for an afternoon pick up I added a shot. This is great to use as a meal replacement or just to get a good amount of protein while enjoying the flavor.

the shake is OK in taste but the clumps of something resembling cottage cheese stay on the bottom no matter how much and how long you shake. I had to run them through the strainer before drinking. I am very sensitive for clumps on stuff in the drink so needless to say it was very difficult to use and will absolutely do not purchase again.