This ultra filtered protein shake tastes just like melted vanilla ice cream and exactly like that other famous brand. The reason I took off one star is because there is a slight odd smell, but you don't taste the smell if that makes sense. Love that it's lower in calories and sugars. Definitely would be something we put on our "always buy" list from Sam's Club.

I've drank a lot of protein shakes and have never liked them. They always leave that gross taste %26 feel in my mouth. These don't. I bought them for my diabetic FIL but even I'm hooked. I tell everyone about them. Low sugar, low carb, high protein. Tip: for added umph, add some toranis sf syrup.

I use protein shakes a few times a week to reach protein intake goals that are so important for overall health. I am quite pleased with the Members Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk Shake, Vanilla and would purchase it again. It has a smooth texture and has a pleasant vanilla taste. The product has a mild medicine-like flavor as well, which is the reason that I did not rate it with 5 stars. However, as stated it is mild and would not deter me from purchasing again. Looking forward to trying other flavors!

It's a decent milkshake without any after taste. The sweeteners used are Monk fruit extract and Stevia leaf extract. Also 30g of protein bottle is pretty good for a milkshake with this price point. Consistency is just a little thicker than milk and it tastes pretty good.

The ONLY drawback to me giving this a 5 star review is the awful aftertaste of the stevia and sucralose. If not for that I would have thought I was drinking a traditional milkshake. It's the first vanilla meal substitute I've EVER come close to liking!!

If i had to be honest, I was a little nervous about trying this particular milk shake. Just nothing against this brand but thinking about previous experiences. I actually decided to try my shake at room temperature and the taste reminded me of cereal. You know when you drink the left over milk after the cereal is gone? Yeah, that's the thought that came to mind.

The kids were excited to try this, especially with the word milk shake on the side and a melted ice cream cone. They said it tasted exactly like melted ice cream and slurped it down super fast. When I could pry one out of their hands and try it, I wasn't as impressed. It did taste like a melted vanilla ice cream cone which was a bit too sweet for my liking. As it was more for me than them, it might be a one time buy. I'd afraid they'd clean them out immediately.

The members mark ultra filtered milkshake tasted very good. It actually tasted like a milkshake and didn't have any after taste at all like some drinks do. It was creamy and I would definitely recommend it for anyone wanting to get some extra protein in their diet.

These vanilla protein shakes are so good! The flavor is perfect and there's no after taste like with most protein shakes. I would love more flavors and will definitely be buying more of these. My husband is also drinking them and has replaced his regular shakes with these.

These milkshakes are delicious. What a great sweet treat. If you are looking for protein, it is in there. I just like these as a liquid dessert. They are just the right size for a treat that isn't overdoing it. I also have used these as creamer in my coffee. If you like some vanilla flavor in your coffee, but don't want the heaviness of a traditional cream, this has great flavor and is a little lighter.