I really love the Fairlife protein shakes, but this one is a little more affordable, and I can't tell the difference. Comparing the nutritional labels, looks the same in that regard too. I gave one to my very picky 9 year old too, and he said it tastes like an In N Out milkshake. They're also shelf stable and not to bad even room temp.

If i had to be honest, I was a little nervous about trying this particular milk shake. Just nothing against this brand but thinking about previous experiences. I actually decided to try my shake at room temperature and the taste reminded me of cereal. You know when you drink the left over milk after the cereal is gone? Yeah, that's the thought that came to mind.

The kids were excited to try this, especially with the word milk shake on the side and a melted ice cream cone. They said it tasted exactly like melted ice cream and slurped it down super fast. When I could pry one out of their hands and try it, I wasn't as impressed. It did taste like a melted vanilla ice cream cone which was a bit too sweet for my liking. As it was more for me than them, it might be a one time buy. I'd afraid they'd clean them out immediately.

These are amazing!! If you love vanilla frosty of half melted vanilla ice cream, vanilla milkshakes these are for you! There's no chemical taste and they legit taste like a vanilla milkshake. The bottle with twist off cap is nice if do t finish all at once. Lactose and gluten free is a perk! And it's not loaded with a boatload of ingredients I can't pronounce! I will be buying these again and trying other flavors. Yum!

Great new shake! It's very smooth tasting and thin. It's not thick and goopy like some shakes. It also doesn't have that protein aftertaste that I hate so much! I have enjoyed it as a coffee creamer, a mid day snack and I like to put instant coffee into the bottle, shake up and drink. It's delicious that way!

The smooth milk like texture surprised me. It was not at all chalky or grainy just smooth. The flavor did not have an artificial after taste and was not to sweet. It's the perfect size and great for throwing in my work bag. Regular milk upsets me in the mornings but i can drink this with no issues.

Smooth and light vanilla shake. Taste just like vanilla ice cream! My favorite way to have this protein shake is to make an ice coffee. A protein packed ice coffee helps me make it to my daily protein goals. I also like to have these in the fridge at all time for a grab and go shake.

These Member's Mark ultra-filtered protein milkshakes are so good!! Had no artificial colors, no growth hormones, and no carrageenan! Vitamin A and D added and ultra pasteurized. There are 30 grams of protein per shake! The vanilla literally tastes like melted ice cream it's so good!!

Tried this flavor for breakfast this morning, cold out of the fridge. Has a good creamy and sweet taste to it. A little sweeter than I prefer but that's just my preference. Not a huge fan of the after taste but it is tolerable. I will at least give a different flavor a try for I give up on the brand.

This vanilla ultra-filtered milkshake is really good—creamy, smooth, and not too sweet. The vanilla flavor tastes clean and natural, and the texture is thick without feeling heavy. It feels more filling than a regular milkshake, which makes it great as a quick snack or treat. I like that it doesn't taste watery or artificial. I'd definitely buy it again.