Not sure why you feel it necessary to package these so different from the chocolate. Same fluid ounce, same # of items in a box (12 vs 15) makes no sense. The square boxes you use for chocolate are much easier to open. Doubt I'll buy the vanilla again unless the packaging changes.

I tried the Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk in the vanilla flavor, and I was pleasantly surprised by how smooth and rich it tasted. The vanilla is subtle but adds just enough sweetness without being overpowering. I also like that it has higher protein and lower sugar compared to regular milk, which makes it feel like a smarter choice. It's become an easy go-to for my morning coffee or a quick, satisfying drink on its own.

I am super picky about protein shakes, and mostly drink the name brand ultra-filtered shakes. When I saw that Member's Mark had a store brand option I was cautiously optimistic. THESE ARE SO GOOD! Not chalky, no weird after taste, and the price point is significantly cheaper than other brands. Definitely take the chance and try these!!

The Members Mark Ultra Filtered Milkshake is a protein drink that tastes great.The vanilla flavor was good, I haven't tasted the other flavors. It is a "milkshake” consistency with 30 grams of protein and only 150 calories. This would be a great snack or meal alternative.

This is a pretty good shake. The taste and smell is a pleasant vanilla without being chalky or with a bad after taste. It's perhaps is a bit watery for my liking, but it does pack a strong protein punch at 30g. At only 150 calories and 2g of sugar, it's a great option to get protein without a bunch of extra calories and sugar.

I recently tried this ultra-filtered protein vanilla shake and found it to be a convenient addition to my routine. I used it at home during dinner as a way to boost the protein content of my meal without having to prepare anything extra. It fit in easily with what I was already eating and didn't require any extra time or effort. The first thing I noticed was the flavor. It had a pleasant vanilla taste that was smooth and enjoyable, not artificial or overly heavy. The consistency was also a big plus—it was thick enough to feel satisfying on its own, but still light enough that I could see it working well as a base for smoothies. I can imagine blending it with fruits like bananas or berries, or even adding vegetables like spinach, for a quick and nutritious drink. What I really liked most was how simple it made adding more protein to my diet. It's an easy option for busy days when I don't want to overthink meals. The only downside for me was the stevia. The sweetness had a slightly overpowering aftertaste that lingered longer than I preferred.

I was VERY well surprised with how delicious this was - not that I thought it wouldn't be good, but the level of taste is better than what I could have imagined. You know when you get that delicious scoop of vanilla ice cream and it's so good you drink the melted part so that none of it is wasted? This is the melted delicious vanilla ice cream in a bottle and with the added bonus of having 30g of protein and only 150 calories! I was actually going to enjoy it with a snack but it was so feeling I was able to just drink it alone, which was a win for me. I would absolutely buy these again in an instant.

These vanilla milk shakes have become part of my morning routine. I grab one on the way out the door and I'm set. No prep, no mess, just a solid 30 grams of protein to start the day. The vanilla flavor has a great taste. That's not always been the case with some brands. It's not overly sweet or chalky, and the protein is smooth with no clumping. For anyone trying to hit protein goals without the hassle of cooking or blending anything, these are a practical option worth keeping in the rotation. The 12-pack size makes it easy to stock up and not think about it for a while. Solid product.

​If you are looking for a protein shake that actually tastes like a treat rather than a chore to drink, the Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Vanilla Protein Shake is a fantastic find. ​The standout feature is the texture. Because it is ultra-filtered, it lacks that chalky or gritty mouthfeel that plagues so many other pre-made shakes. It is incredibly smooth and creamy, reminiscent of a vanilla bean milkshake but without the heavy sugar load. The vanilla flavor is balanced—sweet enough to satisfy a craving but clean enough that it doesn't leave a lingering artificial aftertaste.

This protein drink was surprisingly delicious. I am trying to put more protein in my daily routine and this protein drink tasted lighter than most. They are super creamy, no chalky aftertaste, and they don't upset my stomach. I've tried a lot of protein shakes, and this one is definitely one of the best.