These are actually really good! In comparison to the Nurri Vanilla Protein milkshakes (which are more water-based in comparison), these member’s mark ones are sweet and creamy like an actual shake. Delicious. Will definitely purchase again.

I'm not one to write a review but this protein drink tastes amazing! It's like having a sweet treat but it also has a high protein! Try it! If you don't like it - return it.

I tried it with high hopes. Yes, it has a better vanilla taste than any other shake BUT it has a heavy egg taste and smell. So much that I can't drink it. If they got rid of the egginess, I'd give it a 10 and make it my new shake.

First time trying it and pease make in more flavors! The taste is very good and not chalky like some protein shakes out there. Very tasty and will recommend

These are SO tasty. They are not chalky at all, and not too sweet. I love that they can stay in the pantry until I'm ready to chill a few! Good deal for the price!

Tastes ok, but has a terrible smell. Smells like rotten eggs. If they could make it smell like vanilla it would be a good comparison to fairlife shakes.

First, the packaging is ridiculous. It comes in a sealed box, then have to unwrap plastic around lid, then finally have to pull off aluminum lid. Second, I don't know what flavor this is, but it isn't vanilla. The flavor is awful.

Finally, a vanilla that's good! My husband usually doesn't like protein shakes because of the aftertaste but he loves this one. It's great on its own but my favorite way to have it is with iced espresso. Perfect protein fueled morning drink!

these taste just like Sam's clubs own vanilla frozen yogurt it's delicious! great value too. definitely recommend giving these a try for a ready to drink protein option.

Finally a replacement for fairlife, It's been years since they stopped making the vanilla and this is the first replacement I actually like. The flavor is great and just the right amount of sweetness.