Customer reviews for Member's Mark Fat Free Milk (1 gal.) forMember's Mark Fat Free Milk (1 gal.)
Most helpful positive review
10 customers found this helpful
4 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
The milk is amazing but the container is awful!
LWhite
Most helpful negative review
3 customers found this helpful
1 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Smashed
Family of six
1,633 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/10/2025The milk jug wasn't shaped like this picture. It was taller and the spout was harder to pour from. I won't buy that jug design again.
Strange jug design
Joni - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/12/2024still doesn't smell spoilt 2-3 weeks after opening, usually at other places they spoil within a week -2 weeks
nice and light
Jen - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/30/2023The milk is fine it’s just the dates come up way too fast. I wish they’d grab the newer milks with a later expiration date.
I wish I could get 10 days out of a gallon of milk
Hurf - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase6/28/2025I wanted to buy 1% milk, but had to buy this. This happens regularly. Sam's is out of 1% more often than they have it in stock.
Could not buy what I wanted.
Dane - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/28/2025Why is your milk higher priced than my local grocery store when I have to pay a membership fee to belong?
Milk
Mary - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/5/2024I bought it the 22th sell by date was the 20th...didnt think i had ti check. I guess even a busy Sam's Sam's!
Check date
Cynthia S - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/12/2024I love this milk, and I especially love that it is still great DAYS after the Best By Date. (At least a week!)
Favorite item at Sam's!
BCHC - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase2/14/2024Skim milk, don't like the carton it is in. We have 2x's had spoiled milk. We live to far to just take it back.
Skim milk
BKE - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase3/5/2021I like the milk jug design it is easy to pour into a glass. The milk has great flavor. and the color is white not bluish.
Delish Newtrish Foody
Judy - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase3/30/2021Great tasting and container fits nicely in refrigerator. The price is better than in local grocery stores.
Value for price and great size.
Blue eyes 1952 - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase6/14/2025It comes in containers that are solid white rather than slightly see-through, which means the milk tastes OODLES BETTER!
I love their milk, but I’m done being a customer.
Honest Opinion - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/10/2021Flavorful for fat-free milk, better-tasting than other fat free brands. Keeps a long time (more than 2 weeks) in refrigerator.
Flavorful and keeps more than 2 weeks.
DIY mom - 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/23/2019The milk is good, the jug is junk. Hard to open, and the seal is sometimes difficult to peal without ripping.
Hate the jug, the milk is fine.
602acw - 2 out of 5 stars review11/1/2022Milk is good however can you please remove the annoying seal on the milk… signed ALL DAYCARE PROVIDERS
Cover/seal
seal - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase3/4/2022Bought by accident, still haven't figured out how in the world or why in the world any one would drink the fat free version of milk. Go drink a glass of water.
Buy accident
Chevy - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/1/2020Not a fan. The milk is probably good, but we can't stand fat free milk. I am not sure what happened in the last couple of months, but milk has been sparse for pick up orders and this has been the only thing available.
Not my favorite
S Ray - 3 out of 5 stars review9/12/2022Great milk. Never had an issue with taste. And actually there's been plenty of times that we drank it a week past it's due date. BUT, I have to use a knife to open the seal!! It feels as though it is super glued to the container. It really shouldn't be that difficult to open a gallon of milk.
What's up with the seal?!
My3Sons - 5 out of 5 stars review12/5/2018Just became a member and grateful for the lower price for this fat free milk because it is my favorite. Must be a new container because it has no problem opening and pours with no spills whatsoever. However, the expiration date sometimes is too short, maybe because not enough sold. So, disappointed I have to get the next percent. Wish store would not buy so much so it will come in more and have the same expiration dates as the whole, 2%, and 1% milks. Delicious with ice cubes in hot weather.
Great Milk and Container
Anonymous817 - 5 out of 5 stars review2/11/2019I almost didn’t buy this milk when I saw all the low ratings because of the container change. People had to wait for their husbands to come home and use tools to open it? My thoughts: 1) it’s easy to open with bare hands. I am a 50+ woman with weak hands and the cap just twists off like any other milk container. 2) the next step is to twist the tab on the final seal, which I also can do easily with my bare hands, but if someone uses a little paring knife to cut around the outside it would also open simply. 3) I can understand that people are upset that the new design doesn’t fit in the door . I too used to keep my milk there. But fact is milk doesn’t belong in the door - it spoils faster. Just set it in your fridge on the shelf. 4) l...
container works fine!
emom - 5 out of 5 stars review1/20/2024We love this milk the taste is so much better than any other brand, my grandson (5) even says give me the big white milk over the other store milk. Cartons are somewhat taller than store brand fit in the frig so much better. I'm not a big milk fan myself I do like this milk AND THIS MILK HAS "NO" growth hormones improves the taste ?, stamped right on the carton. We drive 30 miles for this product.
skim milk gallon
lovethis